Margarita’s Pizza
604 W Historic Mitchell St, Milwaukee
(414) 212-8465
Customers' Favorites
Build Your Own
Wings
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
BEST pizza in Milwaukee. It's a little, unassuming business on the southside. Not where you'd think to go for delicious pizza. But it is hands down the best I've had here. And they are so nice! We live down the street so are regulars and she always says hi and it's good to see us again. The food is quick, priced well, and so so so delicious.
This may be a pizzeria but the real gems here are the Mexican food!! That’s probably why the pizza has such bad reviews because their speciality is tamales, empanadas, and mole chicken!! Rosa is the sweetest and always smiling and bubbly. She makes the tastiest, moist, banana leaf wrapped tamals with the perfect ratio of mass and filling. I love meat filling but the rasa con queso is my personal fav. This is definitely a takeout spot and I don’t recommend dining in but if...
The pizza was fresh and had good flavor but they were stingy with the ingredients. By the time the pizza cooled down it was dry because of the lack of cheese, pizza sauce, and toppings. It tasted like I was eating bread. I would order again but If I did I would order extra everything on the pie in order for it to be the way I like my pizza. I felt like it could have been a better value for what I paid. Staff were nice though. I might give it another chance.
You May Also Like
Taqueria El Toro - 551 W Historic Mitchell St
![]()
Tacos, Mexican
Anmol Restaurant - Milwaukee - 711 W Historic Mitchell St
![]()
Pakistani, Indian, Halal, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Bryant's Cocktail Lounge - 1579 S 9th St
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Lounges