Salvatore's Tomato Pies

5507 Monona Dr, Monona
(608) 305-8611

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Fat Uncle Tony Pizza Pepperoni Pizza
Butterscotch Pudding
Butterscotch Budino
Fig and Bacon Pizza
10 Sal’S Supreme
Walter White Pizza
Kids Cheese Pizza
Cauliflower Wings
Gluten Free Crust
Brussels Sprouts

Menu

Appetizers
Chicken Wings
Delicious wings available in buffalo, alabama white BBQ, or korean bbq. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing. Dairy.
Cheddar Cheese Curds
Breaded cheese curds garnished with scallion and served with a side of smoke paprika ranch. Dairy, Wheat, Vegetarian.
Buffalo Cheddar Cheese Curds
Breaded cheese curds tossed and a sriracha dry rub garnished with scallion and served with a side of smoke paprika ranch. Dairy, Wheat, Vegetarian.
Burrata
Mozzarella with mixed greens, cherry tomatoes tossed in red wine vinaigrette, basil oil, fresh basil, and a side of crostini.
Garlic Bread
Baguette, garlic butter, sartori sarvecchio & served with house-made marinara.
Flying Flowers
Battered & fried cauliflower wings. Available in buffalo or korean BBQ. Served with celery & blue cheese dressing. Dairy, Wheat, Vegetarian.
House Meatballs
5 well's farm beef, veal, and pork meatballs, marinara, sartori sar vecchio, with fresh herbs & a toasted baguette. Dairy, Wheat, Shellfish Free, Fish Free.
Slide Gourmet Potato Chips
A collaboration between madison's own slide potato chips and salvatore's these savory chips are inspired by the seasonings that make up our in-house pepperoni blend.

Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine, sarvecchio Parmesan crisps, house caesar dressing & fresh dill. Dairy, Egg, Shellfish Free, Gluten Free, Fish, Soy Free.
Market Salad
Mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, cherry tomatoes, and sarvecchio, served with seasonal vinaigrette. Dairy, Vegetarian.

Subs and Sandwiches
Meatball Sub
House made with wells farms beef, garlic butter, provolone and red sauce on a hoagie roll. Dairy, Wheat.
The Silvio
Spicy boars head capicola, soppressata, and ham, layered thick on Italian deli bread. Topped with sliced provolone, shredded lettuce, sliced tomato, sliced red onion, banana pepper, red wine vinegar and olive oil. Dairy, Wheat.

Specials
Tomato Pie
Mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, roasted garlic, red onion, goat cheese, arugula & red wine reduction.
Fish Friday (Friday Only)
1/2 a pound of beer-battered bluegill, coleslaw, and french fries, with a lemon wedge & creamy caesar-tartar sauce.
16" 1-Topping Deal (Tuesday Only)
Our classic tomato pie is the base for your selection of toppings. Every classic has romano, mozzarella, red sauce, and basil unless otherwise specified. Get 1 topping for free. (delivery/pickup only). Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free, Vegetarian.
Thrifty Thursday Combo (Thursday Only)
Your choice of two 10" specialty pies, an order of wings, and a 2 liter soda.

Specialty Pies
Tomato Pie
Our Classic Tomato Pie is the base for your selection of toppings. The classic, but built in reverse; crust, olive oil, romano, wisconsin whole milk mozzarella, red sauce, finished with fresh basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, in 1910. Dairy, Wheat, Vegetarian.
Terrence's Favorite Pie
Mozzarella, house made red sauce, italian sausage, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions, goat cheese & basil.
Forza Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, tempesta artisan uncured pepperoni, calabrese chili, smoked gouda, sliced garlic, ricotta, and roasted tomato (no red sauce).
Figgettaboudit Pie
We love brussels sprouts. We also love our fig and bacon pizza. We had a crazy idea and now we have the best of both worlds. Whole milk mozzarella, wine poached mission figs, fried shaved Brussels sprouts, bacon, & gorgonzola cheese, finished with balsamic red wine reduction & fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Soy Free.
Fat Uncle Tony Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, Italian sausage, bacon, pepperoni & red sauce finished with fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free.
Fig and Bacon Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, wine poached mission figs, bacon & gorgonzola cheese, finished with balsamic red wine reduction & fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free.
Joey Bananas Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, house red sauce, tempesta uncured pepperoni, fresh jalapenos, banana peppers, sartori montamore, finished with hot honey & fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free.
Phoning It in Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, red sauce, pepperoni, mushroom, yellow onion, green & banana peppers & fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free.
The Vegetarian Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, beet pesto, brussel sprouts, kale, caramelized onion, & goat cheese, finished with balsamic reduction & fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free, Vegetarian.
The Woodsman Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, brown butter sauteed crimini, oyster & shiitake mushrooms with leek, & pleasant ridge reserve, finished with truffle oil, cracked black pepper & chives, can't be made vegan or dairy-free. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free, Vegetarian.
Vegan Supreme Pie
Vegan mozzarella, red sauce, vegan italian sausage, mushroom, yellow onion, and green pepper, finished with fresh basil. Dairy Free, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free, Vegan.
Walter White Pie
Whole milk mozzarella, italian sausage, romano, spinach, ricotta, sliced garlic, calabrese chili, & lemon olive oil, finished with fresh basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free.

Kids' Menu
Kids Cheese Pizza
Our classic tomato pie, with cheese on top and no basil. Dairy, Wheat, Egg Free, Shellfish Free, Fish Free, Soy Free, Vegetarian.

Desserts
Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake with dark chocolate ganache, coconut caramel & whipped cream. Dairy Free, Wheat, Egg Free, Vegetarian, Vegan.
Tiramisu
Espresso-dipped ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese & chocolate sauce. Dairy, Vegetarian.
Butterscotch Budino
A decadent budino served with a pistachio biscotti, whipped cream and smoked salt.

Drinks
Soft Drinks
2L Soda
Choose your 2L drink option

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

our 4th time there since we got back from Florida. the pizza pies are great. service great. Emily made sure our group of 7 was well served. She even held mine back a little to make sure mine was more crispy before bringing it to the table. The atmosphere is warm and cozy. i like the pies better than Porta Bella. Paisans was always our favorite but it has not returned so Salvatore’s has replaced it. We will go there when we want pizza.
July 2025
It had a very weird feel because it is decorated to give an old-world Italian feel, with antique pictures and such on the walls, but then there's random things, like a giant feather lamp shade or a French horn lamp, that seem out of place. They also had a top 40 internet radio station with ads playing loud enough that it was disruptive towards conversation. It kind of felt like the place didn't know what it wanted to be, between being casual and formal. Would probably...
July 2025
Food is fantastic. We had cheese curds and garlic bread, we had them add bacon. For 4 people we shared 16 inch Fat Tony's pizza and Joey's Banana. The Joey's had a sweet heat which worked so well with that pizza. It was more than enough food and we had slices to take home. The Butterscotch Budino we shared and it delicious.
The music playing was slightly louder than necessary. They had a football game on which was a good distraction. The lighting was dimmer...
December 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

La Choza Del Viejo (The Best Chinese Food) - 5415b Monona Dr
Chinese, Seafood, Soup
Cousins Subs - 5413 Monona Dr
Sandwich Shop, Salad
Fratelli's Trattoria - 5801 Monona Dr
Italian, Pizza, Seafood

Salvatore's Tomato Pies

5507 Monona Dr, Monona, WI 53716
(608) 305-8611