Schwarz's Supper Club

W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein
(920) 894-3598

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Desperate Housewife After Dinner Drink
Tenderloin with Boasted Potatoes
Tenedeloin and Lobster Tail
Prime Rib Dinner for 2 Rare
Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Tenderloin with Scallops
Old Fashion Brandy Sweet
Tenderloin with Shrimp
Large T-Bone Dinner
Onion Ring Haystack

Menu

Chicken and Pork
Petite Broiled Chicken Breast (8 oz)
Two 8 oz boneless and skinless. Topped with a homemade wine sauce.
Chicken Dinner (1/2)
Breast, wing, thigh, and leg.
BBQ Pork Back Ribs
Baked and served with an all-natural sweet and tangy barbecue sauce.
Grilled Pork Chops (8 oz)
Two 8 oz chops 1-inch thick cut. Served with applesauce.
Petite Grilled Pork Chop (8 oz)
Two 8 oz chops 1-inch thick cut. Served with applesauce.
Broiled Chicken Breast (8 oz)
Two 8 oz boneless and skinless. Topped with a homemade wine sauce.

Land and Sea
Steak and Shrimp
Medium sirloin tips or petite prime rib 8-10 oz and choice of three grilled shrimp, three breaded fantail shrimp or six breaded scallops.
Petite Steak and Shrimp
Small sirloin tip 6 oz and choice of three grilled shrimp, three breaded fantail shrimp or six breaded scallops.
Petite Steak and Grilled Scallops
Small sirloin tip 6 oz and three large grilled sea scallops topped with a homemade pesto-garlic butter.
Steak and Lobster
Petite Steak and Lobster
Small sirloin tip 6 oz and one cold water Canadian lobster tail 8-10 oz.

Appetizers
Cheese Nuggets
Served with marinara sauce.
Cauliflower
Breaded with cheese and deep-fried and served with ranch dressing.
Italian Breaded Mozzarella Sticks
Eight mozzarella cheese sticks breaded and served with marinara sauce.
Schwarz's Combo Plate
Four mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and cheese nuggets. Served with ranch dressing and marinara sauce.
Crab Cakes
Two deep-fried cakes filled with stuffing and crab meat. Served with homemade dill sauce.
Tempura Shrimp
Approximately eight, lightly breaded shrimp and served with a sesame ginger sauce.
Shrimp Cocktail
Four shrimp steamed on order, chilled, and served with homemade cocktail sauce.
Buttermilk Breaded Popcorn Shrimp (8 oz)
Breaded bite-size shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce.
Clam Strips
Served with homemade cocktail sauce.
Blue Balls
Five chicken cordon bleu bites lightly breaded and served with ranch dressing.
Quesadilla Rolls
Four sticks rolled in tortillas with Wisconsin cheese, chicken, and jalapenos. Served with sour cream.
Tornado Rancher
Four savory shredded steak, real cheeses, and a zesty red sauce in a crispy seasoned tortilla and served with ranch dressing.
Calamari
Lightly breaded and served with marinara sauce.
Spanakopita
Six light and flaky filo dough triangles filled with creamy spinach, feta cheese, onion, garlic, and spices. Served with marinara sauce.

Kid's Corner
Chicken Bites
Four deep-fried tenders.
Mini Corn Dogs
Six deep-fried mini corn dogs.
Macaroni Cheese Bites
Deep-fried wedges of macaroni and cheese.
Popcorn Shrimp
Deep-fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+74 photos
Photo credit: google
+73 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Great supper club. All of our food was very good. Friendly service, too. My prime rib was tender and tasty. The double baked potato was just right. Cheese cake was big and scrumptious.
October 2025
Our first experience visiting… a little nervous because we didn’t know how it worked, but it was great. Get a menu, pick out your food, stand your menu up and boom they take your order and call you to your table when it is ready. The salad is already set and you sit to eat. The food was delicious, I loved the Union rings and crab cakes plus the prime rib was delicious!

I highly recommend and will eat here again!
October 2025
Omg our first visit today blown away they don’t take reservations but their process is one of a kind. We never waited to eat, the entire staff were very welcoming and our food was delicious had to bring a doggy bag home
Thank you from Beaver dam well worth the drive
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Jovans' Pub - W8503 Co Rd Q
Bar & Grill
Isaac's Sports Bar & Grill - 2122 Wisconsin Ave
Bar & Grill, Bar, Barbeque
Dilly’s 7 Corners - W505 Fur Farm Rd
Bar, Bar & Grill, American

Schwarz's Supper Club

W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061
(920) 894-3598