The Rivalry Pub

6996 Pennsylvania St, Oconomowoc
(262) 567-7833

Recent Reviews

Photos

+18 photos

+17 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Based on the reviews we could have had a less than high standard ecxperience at The Rivalry Pub. Atmosphere is terrific, service very good, but the food was average. Onion rings were very overcooked and you could see that by the appearance and with the onions dried out under the batter coating. Smoked meat sandwich of the day (chicken) was nothing more than a pulled pork chicken with seemingly artificial smoked taste on a very plain bun. No extra sauce, no pickle no lettuce no...

August 2025

My wife and I have tried to enjoy a meal and drinks at Rivalry Pub 4 times now and have only been able to enjoy the pub once. The restaurant appears to be struggling to find its "groove" this year. The last 2 attempts to dine and drink here resulted in an ice cold fish fry that took an hour to get (seems it sat in the kitchen for some time before being brought out as the fries were soggy and cold and the fish that was over fried was mushy and cold as well. Wanting to...

January 2023

We enjoy the food and atmosphere! The putting course while you wait for your food is also fun. I have enjoyed several entrees and have yet to be disappointed. Outdoor seating is pleasant and the inside is very comfortable. Friendly staff as well!

August 2022

More Reviews

Restaurants in Oconomowoc, WI

The Rivalry Pub

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

The Rivalry Pub