7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Onalaska

“This is a customizable frozen pizza joint, keep expectations at that level. The people working were very kind, the pizza was there and all the customizations were met (we have a dairy allergy, and they were able to do vegan cheese which is rare in this area) the kids enjoyed the make your own pizza and the price point for those was perfect. The stuffed crust is basically Freschetta frozen pizza, the calzone was made to order (with the vegan cheese) and it was very tasty according to those who tried it.
If you're expecting gormet pizza? Don't go here. If you need a quick meal with some fun options to fill the tank? Papa Murphy's is a solid choice.“

“I was delighted to see Jonna back in the drive-through today! She is always so upbeat, friendly, and accommodating! glad you're back!“

“This place is a well-kept secret! We got a gift card last Christmas and until then, I'd only driven by it. But today was probably the tenth time I've picked up pizzas to go, and they're the best around.I work in Foodservice, and I appreciate the extra-effort these guys put into their product. I've probably picked up or received delivery for well over a thousand pizzas, and the number one complaint with a lot of places is that the pizza isn't hot. Not with these guys - the first time I got home and opened a pizza box from Big Al's Too, I was blown away - they put their pizzas on a cardboard circle and also wrap their pizzas in foil. You know why everyone doesn't do this? Because it's EXPENSIVE, that's why. I use aluminum foil at work every single day and I can tell you that the price has almost doubled in the last few years. But you know what's also doubled? The temperature when you stick your hand in the box when you rip off the foil - look out, that pizza is smoking hot. But it makes a huge difference. I got pulled over a few months ago for speeding on the way home, and it took the guys a little bit to run my license and registration, but the pizza was still steaming hot when I got home and everyone was happy.If you haven't tried this place, give it a shot - you'll be glad you did.“

“We got toppers tonight, great as always! Amazing combinations along with a great crust makes for a great pizza night!

Service was excellent! We had a large order and they offered to help carry the pizzas to our vehicle.

Don’t forget topper stix! My in-laws ordered the dill pickle topper stix, they were freakishly good! This coming from a guy that can’t stand pickles.

Thanks Toppers!“

“My wife and I stopped by last Friday (9/12/2025). Our first choice (suggested by our host) was the Red Pines Bar and Grill, but after being notified that it would be a 45-minute wait, we decided to go to Angelinis. We are so glad we did! Our first time in a real Italian restaurant. The waiter, after giving me a quick lesson in the correct pronunciation of "bruschetta," was very amiable and professional. A wonderful young man! The food was fantastic. The service was excellent, but the lighting was a little lacking. Some people were using their phone's flashlight to read the menu. Added Angelinis to our "Must Return If In The Area" list! Well done!“

“This new crew is doing a much better job with the quality of pizza and with their service!

There is a steady stream of customers again, so others have also noticed.

Whether early or late I would have hated to lose this dining option.“

“I would like to give a huge THANK YOU!! to the Domino Pizza in Onalaska! Your customer service and delivery goes above and beyond!“