Insomnia Cookies
547 High Ave, Oshkosh
(920) 349-1551
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Chip
Chocolate Chip
Brownie
Sundae
Cookie
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The cookies are amazing. They just need to learn how to cook them a little longer because there’s no reason why I just ordered cookies from there and there’s still doughy in the middle like I shouldn’t have to taste the batter in the middle so I had
To put them in my oven too cook a lil longer other than that, they’re amazing also, when you try to call to speak to someone, no one answers the phone and their voicemail is full so you can’t even leave a message
To put them in my oven too cook a lil longer other than that, they’re amazing also, when you try to call to speak to someone, no one answers the phone and their voicemail is full so you can’t even leave a message
The cookies are tasty but are very expensive. I like the idea of them being warm, but it's like heat lamp warm, so they get a bit dried out. The melted chocolate chips hide that a bit. I'm sure the ice cream helps too.
There were only 2 ice cream flavors available when we were there, (which should never happen in the state of WI) and neither were options I wanted to make a cookie sandwich out of so I was disappointed and just ate cookies.
The seating...
There were only 2 ice cream flavors available when we were there, (which should never happen in the state of WI) and neither were options I wanted to make a cookie sandwich out of so I was disappointed and just ate cookies.
The seating...
You May Also Like
Mama's Noodle Bar - 248 Wisconsin St
![]()
Asian, Thai, Korean, Asian Fusion, Vegetarian
Polito’s Pizza - 543 High Ave
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian, Vegan
Niko's Gyros - 532 Campus Pl
![]()
Mediterranean, Greek, Vegetarian
The counter dude/ baker was awesome. Extremely friendly, very professional, polite and respectful.
He had the best customer service attitude!
As always, the cookies were amazing!
Love the Insomnia Cookies?