21 Best Bakeries near Pleasant Prairie

“Enjoyable place to eat. Kind staff and good food

Parking: The parking is very cramped and annoying but overall I would say it is worth it just to be able to eat here.

Kid-friendliness: Nice atmosphere and good decorations. There are modern elements like tablets to order on and displays of the cookies.

Wheelchair accessibility: Can roll wheelchair, might have trouble because of the curb but overall, not hard for wheelchairs.“

“This location is great! The staff is always super friendly and welcoming. The cakes are delicious. You can order ahead of time on the app or website and pick up at your convenience. There is also a rewards program where you can earn points towards future purchases! The cakes are so moist and the frosting is delicious. There are several options for decorating your cake for any and all occasions too!!! They also have two gluten free options which are tasty!!! Highly recommend!!!“

“Visited the store with my good friend who was visiting from out of state. Great prices on great Pepperidge Farm snacks! The Manager, Kim B., explained that the product may be past their "sell by" date, but the product is still good for 3 months after that date. We stocked up on our favorite snacks; cookies and Goldfish crackers, and left thrilled with our purchases! Next time I think I'll purchase one of their cakes in the refrigerated section, they looked really good!“

“Not sure how long this location has been here but this past August was the first time in at least a couple of years having this in general.

Churros have always been pretty good here if not a bit pricy and for some Mexican/American-born Mexican co-workers of mine; only average.

I guess for them it's the authenticity factor but to each their own. Yes I've had churros from local-owned panaderias in the Chicago area that taste better but for a quick bite while roaming around the outlets, not bad at all.

My kids are always worth a stop anywhere for dessert when they have a specific craving so a stop back here is likely, hope for continued boomin' business for the owner(s).“

“We just stopped in passing thru town today- such a cute little shop, super friendly, and AMAZING cheesecake! We’ll make it a point to visit more often. Recommend!“

“They have very good doughnuts Love their bakery. Donuts always fresh. So many to pick from. Been a customer since 1982. Tried others but there is no comparison.“

“Nice vibe, I love what they did with the space they have, the people are friendly the sweets are AMAZING! Their apple pie changed my life!“

“March 6, 2026 After calling Many stores about a birthday cake for my husband, I called Oliver’s and it was the first time. A man answered and after telling him I needed a cake that day that looked special and he first said you need it today? I said yes I screwed up and he said let me check and he came back said this is what I have and it was perfect. In 30 minutes he had the writing done and he got me out of not having a cake. Thank you. One very pleased customer.“

“We visited today for the first time after driving by for many many years. I was pleasantly surprised. We had an affordable (not healthy) lunch that was so big we could have split. Had lots of delicious cheese and bakery samples. Purchased quite a few souvenirs too. It was a great experience and we’re so glad we finally stopped!!! The Mars Cheese Castle was worth the visit! We saw license plates from atleast 10 different states in the parking lot so I hope everyone had a great experience too!“

“Your Frosted Animal Cookie Cheesecake was phenomenal!“

“This place CJ‘s coffeehouse is the best donut shop I’ve ever gone to.. Dunkin’ Donuts is pathetic in comparison. their donuts are far more superior. There’s more Dunkin’ Donuts close by me, but I go all the way to Zion for my donuts.. kudos to CJ’s!!!!“

“all of the pastries are all good and yummmy“

“Porque ase un sabroso 😋😋😋😋 pan 🍞 y nos ricos 😋😋😋pasteles 🎂🎂🥮🥮“

“They play Jesus music. Otherwise I like it a lot. My review has nothing to do with my belief. I just don't like Christian rock. It all sounds like the same song. Learned of this coffee through an event for charity. Delish“

“Best bread in existence! Try the Round. It's hearth baked and tastes so good! These guys inspired me to bake bread since nothing like it exists after moving to Missouri post high school. Cardinali's is true old school craftsmanship (hand shaped and hearth baked - on a stone) as opposed to the machine made chain driven oven mass produced product at the other bakery in Kenosha. There's a difference! I grew up eating both bakery's bread. Now as a baker, I understand why my grandparents (1920-2000) bought all (or mostly all) Cardinali's. It's a true artisan bread. There's nothing else like it (anywhere)! Tip... buy more than you need. FREEZE what you won't eat right away. Thaw what you need for the next day overnight.“

“We ordered a vanilla cake for our son’s birthday and it was delicious! We just told them SpongeBob theme and they did an excellent job decorating it. We have also got other pan dulce here and it’s really good. I am learning Spanish so this was a good opportunity to practice, they only speak Spanish here.“

“Delish gluten free cookies!! And the way she is able to decorate them is so impressive!!“

“They were great and the cake was amazing! My daughter absolutely loved her birthday cake! Thanks again for a great experience.“

“Fantastic pumpkin latte! Going back for cruffins tomorrow!“