Cimaroli's Supper Club

W11793 WI-127, Portage
(608) 742-2238

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Flat Iron Steak Dinner with Italian Potatoes
Flat Iron Steak and Lobster Tail
Steak and Baked Potato
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Raspberry Cheesecake
Double Chocolate Cake
Baked Potatoes
Grass Hoppers
Clam Chowder
Jumbo Shrimp

Menu

Appetizers
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Topped with baked parmesan, served with warm fried tortillas.
Calamari
Served with homemade marinara sauce.
Grilled Chicken Buffalo Tenders
5 oz. Breast grilled and served in our buffalo sauce.
Grilled Chicken Italian Tenders
5 oz breast grilled and served in our garlic sauce.
Escargot
Served with fried bread.
Clam Strips
Deep-fried served with cocktail sauce.
Corn Nuggets
Served with homemade honey butter.
Cheese Curds
Clams Casino
Served with a dinner roll.
Portabella Mushroom
A large portabella lightly battered, served with ranch sauce.
Shrimp Cocktail (3 jumbo)
Crab Dip
A large portion of crab dip is served with fried bread.
Homemade Onion Loaf
Tender, sweet onions sliced thin, dipped in batter, and cooked to a golden brown.
Steiney Sticks
Real mozzarella served with homemade marinara sauce.

USDA Choice Steaks
Tenderloin (10 oz)
The cook's favourite, 10oz.
Chopped Sirloin
Black Angus beef, 6oz.
Tenderloin (5 oz)
The most tender, 5oz.
Ribeye
Marbled for tenderness and flavour.
Ranch Steak
Cut from shoulder centre, 5 oz.
T - Bone
The king of steaks, 12oz.

Seafood
Stuffed Shrimp
4, stuffed with Monterey jack and crab.
Shrimp
8, lightly battered or scampi.
Frog Legs
Half lb., lightly battered or scampi.
Jumbo Shrimp
5, lightly battered or scampi.
Walley
6oz. Filet lightly battered or broiled.
Salmon
6 oz. Parmesan encrusted.
Scallops Vermouth (half lb)
Alaskan Halibut (8 oz filet)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+72 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+71 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

My wife had a flat iron stake, I had the roast duck with lingonberries, both were fantastic! Our old fashioned's were superb! We also had the crab dip appetizer, it was amazing!
We arrived at 4:20 and we were seated immediately. It was very full by 5pm on a Saturday. We will definitely be back!
February 2026
Nice place with good tasting food. Our server, Roseann, was excellent and really made the night a great one. Would recommend coming just for her.
Be aware that the male at the desk was very rude. Everyone else was great. Stopped me from giving a 5 star it was so offputting.
January 2026
We're so happy we made the 35 min drive from Madison to check out Cimaroli's! It reminds you of a upscale Wisconsin supperclub, minus the City prices. The main bar looks exactly out of the 1940's. The recently renovated dining room was upscale, yet casual with a hidden second, overflow bar! They really promote their flat iron steak (for a reason)This tender, buttery cut was amazing. We also ordered the Prime Rib. Not as good, but still outstanding! The Old Fashioned's...
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Foxy's - W8554 Park St
Bar, Vegetarian
The Cove Supper Club - 156 WI-23
American, Pizza, Seafood
Triple Play Sports Bar & Grill - W12907 WI-16
Sports Bar, Burgers, Pizza

Cimaroli's Supper Club

W11793 WI-127, Portage, WI 53901
(608) 742-2238