New American Restaurants near Sauk City, WI

“Absolutely the best in the area. Delicious food, super friendly staff, quick carryouts, great outdoor venue for local bands, always something going on no matter what time of the year. Bobbi and Matt have restored this place better than it ever was; lots of local history.“

“We just had lunch at the shack and everything was so good! 10 out of 10 recommended. I had the tack chicken bowl and it was delicious. Fried pickles were awesome too!“

“We had our first dinner tonight at the Old Feed Mill! First, we were so impressed by the cleanliness of the restaurant. The waitstaff were very friendly and the warm homemade bread they serve is out of this world delicious. Our first round of drinks were spot on. The old fashions had just the right amount of sweet with a healthy portion of bitters and enough brandy to make my light weight cheeks flush. LOL! There were 3 different entrees ordered: chicken picatta, deep fried cod, deep fried walleye. Both fish dishes had the deep fried potato slices and the chicken dishes were served with root veggies and rice pilaf. The chicken was so tender and smothered in this light and buttery sauce. The pilaf was very tasty and so were the veggies. Both fish dishes were very delicious with the right portions of fish and potatoes. They also had a side of coleslaw. Everything was gone when we were done (well those of us who ordered the fish). The chicken dishes were so large we had to take a portion home. We’ve lived in mount Horeb for 8 years and this is our first visit. Can’t believe we haven’t found this gem sooner. This is a restaurant we will definitely go back to frequently. The last comment I’ll make is that it was also very reasonably priced. For two people, 4 drinks, 2 entrees, side salads and 1 dessert it was $82.00. That’s typical prices for just the food in some areas of Dane County!“

“Wonderful food and service! Love that you serve Icelandic Haddock! The best!“