Great place to eat and the drinks are very good also . Be there when it opens though .
Lori Kohn
Alway have a great time. The service is awesome. The people are very inviting.
curt van
Awesome food and drinks
Mark Spietz
Loved it
Jonathan Wilber
Cocktails, dinner, desert, and after dinner drinks for 4! Everything was amazing. The owner was behind the packed bar and made sure to verbally acknowledge that she saw us - which was great because it was packed. She took time when she had it to show us first timers the menu, the summer menu and highlight a great desert. The steaks, fish, and special were all amazing. Salad bar and the hot bacon dressing we added was the best ever. Service was phenomenal. We definitely recommend and can’t wait to go back! Thanks Jeannine, Lydia, and the crew!
Jacqueline Cassandra
Anytime I’ve gone here the food and staff have always been so amazing even when slam packed busy!! Tons of drink options, specials, and a large salad bar as well.
Neale Hunter
First time and Krabbes. A bit of a wait but the drinks were good while we waited, good martini selection. Good salad bar, great French onion soup, and a delicious ribeye!
Daisy Alsteen
We were going to try our “normal” go to menu item but decided to try their specials instead and wow the Island mango salmon, Cabernet kissed tenderloin and the Strawberry rhubarb whiskey old-fashioned where to die for!! They were the best!!!!!
Nick Van Dinter
It was a rainy, wet Tuesday night … we decided to go to Krabbe’s Supper Club, just south of Seymour. This was our first time there. It was chilly when we first arrived, but it warmed up with the help of two wonderful bartenders and, of course, a drink or two. We had come early, and the service was very good with a great waitress. It was unusual, but the four of us had seafood with two of us having perch, one having salmon, and the other having lobster.
One of our requirements is that the supper club has a salad bar. Krabbe’s salad bar is small and does not include soup. But we found the salad bar to be adequate. And, yes, soup is extra.
The portions were above average except for the lobster, which was larger than expected.
From the outside, the building looked average, but inside it was clean, modern, and pleasant.
We will be back!
Kirt Schubring
This place is fantastic. My wife had the Tuscan Scallops and I had the Chicken Supreme. Will definitely be back soon.
One of the best supper clubs around apps,sandwiches,steaks, and seafood, everything on the menu is out of this world. Chef definitely knows what she is doing in the kitchen, winning a burger contest in the area as well, just tells you she is on her game!
That with an amazing bar staff that knows how to make the perfect drink. Definitely a must stop when in the area!
Rob-Crista Schreiber
Where do I start! Salad bar is very sad. 🙁 No cucumbers or tomatoes. Rotten mushrooms. Limited dressings. Ordered tenderloin. No seasoning at all on the steak. Canned mushrooms. Bread was dry. Very weak old fashions. Not going back. Not impressed at all.
Susie Ashford Ossmann
Had an amazing dinner tonight. Started with tasty old fashioneds at the bar. I had the New York strip and it was delish!!!
Jodi Gunderson
The food was delicious!! We went right to table and had salad bar and little while later our main course came. My husband had stuffed primerib and I had tenderloin and haddock.
We will be back
J. Staley
My wife and I stopped in on a Friday at 530 knowing there would be a wait, which we prefer as it's kind of the whole point of supper clubs in general. We live in west central WI and like trying new supper clubs. We waited roughly an hour to order while we talked with very friendly locals and the bartenders. Drinks were great and inexpensive. They run this place like all the old clubs by us used to, order from the bar, then you're seated once your table is ready, they give you ample time to eat your salad before serving the meals. Food was great, steaks were cooked perfectly. When in the area we will definitely be coming back.
As a side note, when you stop into a place that is 2 deep all the way around the bar with people standing, I generally assume that it's going to be good time, just chill out and have a couple drinks, if you want to show up and eat in 30 min, go to pizza hut. The negative reviews of supper clubs having long wait times doesn't seem fair, they aren't fast food joints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Twice Baked Potato, Tenderloin Steak
Great place to eat and the drinks are very good also . Be there when it opens though .
Alway have a great time. The service is awesome. The people are very inviting.
Awesome food and drinks
Loved it
Cocktails, dinner, desert, and after dinner drinks for 4! Everything was amazing. The owner was behind the packed bar and made sure to verbally acknowledge that she saw us - which was great because it was packed. She took time when she had it to show us first timers the menu, the summer menu and highlight a great desert. The steaks, fish, and special were all amazing. Salad bar and the hot bacon dressing we added was the best ever. Service was phenomenal. We definitely recommend and can’t wait to go back! Thanks Jeannine, Lydia, and the crew!
Anytime I’ve gone here the food and staff have always been so amazing even when slam packed busy!! Tons of drink options, specials, and a large salad bar as well.
First time and Krabbes. A bit of a wait but the drinks were good while we waited, good martini selection. Good salad bar, great French onion soup, and a delicious ribeye!
We were going to try our “normal” go to menu item but decided to try their specials instead and wow the Island mango salmon, Cabernet kissed tenderloin and the Strawberry rhubarb whiskey old-fashioned where to die for!! They were the best!!!!!
It was a rainy, wet Tuesday night … we decided to go to Krabbe’s Supper Club, just south of Seymour. This was our first time there. It was chilly when we first arrived, but it warmed up with the help of two wonderful bartenders and, of course, a drink or two. We had come early, and the service was very good with a great waitress. It was unusual, but the four of us had seafood with two of us having perch, one having salmon, and the other having lobster.
One of our requirements is that the supper club has a salad bar. Krabbe’s salad bar is small and does not include soup. But we found the salad bar to be adequate. And, yes, soup is extra.
The portions were above average except for the lobster, which was larger than expected.
From the outside, the building looked average, but inside it was clean, modern, and pleasant.
We will be back!
This place is fantastic. My wife had the Tuscan Scallops and I had the Chicken Supreme. Will definitely be back soon.
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best supper clubs around apps,sandwiches,steaks, and seafood, everything on the menu is out of this world. Chef definitely knows what she is doing in the kitchen, winning a burger contest in the area as well, just tells you she is on her game!
That with an amazing bar staff that knows how to make the perfect drink. Definitely a must stop when in the area!
Where do I start! Salad bar is very sad. 🙁 No cucumbers or tomatoes. Rotten mushrooms. Limited dressings. Ordered tenderloin. No seasoning at all on the steak. Canned mushrooms. Bread was dry. Very weak old fashions. Not going back. Not impressed at all.
Had an amazing dinner tonight. Started with tasty old fashioneds at the bar. I had the New York strip and it was delish!!!
The food was delicious!! We went right to table and had salad bar and little while later our main course came. My husband had stuffed primerib and I had tenderloin and haddock. We will be back
My wife and I stopped in on a Friday at 530 knowing there would be a wait, which we prefer as it's kind of the whole point of supper clubs in general. We live in west central WI and like trying new supper clubs. We waited roughly an hour to order while we talked with very friendly locals and the bartenders. Drinks were great and inexpensive. They run this place like all the old clubs by us used to, order from the bar, then you're seated once your table is ready, they give you ample time to eat your salad before serving the meals. Food was great, steaks were cooked perfectly. When in the area we will definitely be coming back.
As a side note, when you stop into a place that is 2 deep all the way around the bar with people standing, I generally assume that it's going to be good time, just chill out and have a couple drinks, if you want to show up and eat in 30 min, go to pizza hut. The negative reviews of supper clubs having long wait times doesn't seem fair, they aren't fast food joints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Twice Baked Potato, Tenderloin Steak
Loading...