Geno Nottolini's Pizza
1235 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan
(920) 458-4505
Customers' Favorites
Enchiladas
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Haven't actually eaten there yet . Read all the reviews and their average is brought down by people making multiple identical bad reviews . Most of the bad reviews are about management and staff . New owners , almost all of the food reviews are 5 ? . Give it a try and decide for yourself
Good food, mediocre service. Usually very late to arrive, commonly delivers incorrect order, and usually cold by delivery. Terrible customer service from the man that answers the phones. Love the chicken and to be honest some of the food is top notch. Order early if you want any luck
The food is spectacular. The Chicago Style pizza is my favorite. Maybe the best pizza in Sheboygan? Definitely the most underrated. They also have a lot of other things besides pizza. Their Rick's special beef sandwich is fantastic, they have very good wings, and a lots of other things I haven't tried yet. This may be my favorite restaurant in town.
You May Also Like
The End Zone - 904 Indiana Ave
![]()
Bar, Sports Bar
Nine-O-Two on the Avenue - 902 Indiana Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Pubs