Nicky's Pizza
CLOSED$$ •
About Nicky's Pizza
Nicky's Pizza Reviews
Amazing thin HOMEMADE crust! BEST PIZZA IN SHEBOYGAN!
Good pizza, they will really be missed when they close. Thanks for all the years of awesome
We ordered around 8pm tonight (Monday) on a whim because we hadn't had Nicky's in years! The staff was super friendly, our sausage pizza was amazing and huge! The cheese curds were plentiful and delicious as well! Their ranch tastes homemade and was great with the pizza and curds! We got a ton of food for the price and definitely will be back!!
Nicky's Pizza serves delicious and huge pizzas, like their sausage pizza, along with plentiful and tasty cheese curds. The staff is friendly, kind, and courteous. The restaurant offers a great value for the price, and their homemade-tasting ranch is a great addition. While some may find the flavor simple and plain, many consider it some of the best pizza they've had.