Sheboygan Pasty Company
$ • Italian
Hours:
811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan
(920) 395-2132
About Sheboygan Pasty Company
Customers' Favorites
Appetizer Pasty
Breakfast Pasty
Dinner Pasty
Traditional
Sheboygan
Italian
Sheboygan Pasty Company Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 6PM |
People in Sheboygan Also Viewed
Geno Nottolini's Pizza
Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings
Harry’s Prohibition Bistro
Fine Dining, Pizza, Bar
Trattoria Stefano
Italian, Vegan, Vegetarian
.jpg)
Sheboygan Pasty Company, located in the back of Four of a Kind bar, serves authentic pasties reminiscent of those found in the Upper Peninsula. The Traditional UP Pasty is a highlight, with a light and flaky crust and dense, tasty filling. Be sure to add gravy for an extra buck. The menu also features other varieties, including the Sheboygan Pasty with bratwurst. The bar offers a separate menu with soups and other options for those who don't want a pasty. While the atmosphere is casual and neighborhood-bar-like, the service is friendly, and the prices on drinks are hard to beat, especially on Sundays when Happy Hour lasts all day. Customers have shared that the place feels nostalgic of Wisconsin pub and food traditions, and the food is delicious and reasonably priced. Many enjoy the comfort food and fresh ingredients, with some ordering for takeout and delivery, praising the quick and polite service. The pasties, including the Thanksgiving Pasty, are popular, and the food is considered a great, affordable treat. However, some find the texture of the main pasties a bit unusual, and the fudge may not meet everyone's expectations. Vegetarian options are limited, but food is labeled clearly for dietary restrictions. Overall, Sheboygan Pasty Company is a great spot for a tasty and affordable meal in a casual setting.