Uptown Slice
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout Uptown Slice
Customers' Favorites
Apple Bacon Gorgonzola House White Pie
Chicken and Hot Peppers House Red Pie
Sausage Giardiniera House Red Pie
Uptown Margherita House Red Pie
Market Garden House White Pie
Apple Bacon Gorgonzola Slice
Uptown Funk House White Pie
Gio's Meat House Red Pie
Bee Sting House Red Pie
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Uptown Slice Reviews
253 ratings
Share your opinion about Uptown Slice
The ingredients are fresh. Flavors are bursting. Service is amazing. Beer and wine selection is vast. Love seeing what new pizzas and other menu items are available weekly. Highly recommend Uptown Slice for dine in or carry out.
Pizza was awesome! Definitely recomend!
I wanted a great first meal for 2026, and Uptown Slice delivered. Online ordering was easy, and pick up was quick. The quality of both the pizza and tiramisu we got were excellent. Good selection of alcoholic and NA beverages to add on. Highly recommended!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 7PM |
Uptown Slice offers New York-style pizza with a magic crust that should be easy to hold. The food is still fantastic, with quality toppings and an outstanding flavor, cheese, and crust texture and taste. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere make it a great spot for a slice or a whole pie, earning it the title of Sheboygan's best-kept secret for pizza. Customers mention the pizza reminds them of the kind they grew up with, with a legit NY crust - crisp exterior and soft/airy interior. The place is just a couple doors down from City Bakery, giving customers two reasons to make the trip. The owner's baking skills are praised, with customers describing the pizzas as "glorious" and the aroma as "amazing." Overall, Uptown Slice is a must-visit for authentic New York-style pizza in Sheboygan.