Analog Ice Cream and Coffee
10649 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay
(920) 854-1155
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Ice Cream
Breakfast Burrito
Cafe Caramel
Scone
Menu
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Super fun little ice cream and coffee shop with fresh baked goods as well, that are made on site. The layers in those croissants were talking to me. Tried the apple pie ice cream and it was amazing. Like, my favorite dessert in a waffle cone. What more could you ask for? Staff was fantastic and very friendly. Keep up the great work.
Very good ice cream. We enjoyed the vanilla, mint chocolate chip, and our favorite, espresso oreo. It's a really small place, so it can get crowded, but service was super friendly and fast.
Visited Saturday night, July 19th 2025. It was a super busy night we went for a swim off the deck on the sister Bay pier and then for ice cream. Chocolate shop brand ice cream, never disappoints lots of variety of different flavors from mango with Tanjin to lemon meringue and Zanzibar. The downside was they would not give you two different types of ice cream with the kid or single scoop. You had to get the double scoop to be able to have two different kinds of ice cream in your...
You May Also Like
Door County Creamery - 10653 N Bay Shore Dr
![]()
American, Cheese Shops, Pet Friendly
Sister Bay Bowl - 10640 N Bay Shore Dr
![]()
Bowling, American