Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay

Great place that handles big groups and small parties equally well. Terrific servers, hosts, kitchen staff. Very welcoming!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our server Alex was wonderful!! He was attentive and helpful. We were a group of 8 including 2 children and he managed everything very well. He was friendly and knowledgeable. Thanks for a great experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I even learned how to toss dough 😍😍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loved the margarita pizza had it two nights in a row!! The small was perfect size for my sisters and I! So tasty! Would recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Such amazing food and service! Mary, you’re a star! I’m really impressed with how cool you kept it when dealing with the most obnoxious group of customers I’ve ever seen in my life!

I wasn't expecting the pizza to be as good as it was! It's a pretty busy place (both locations) so we prefer to order ahead and take out. I love that you can get the special pizzas half and half!

This zza is sooo so good - totally worth the sit down! The service was even better, thanks Erica for being so kind and attentive 🫶🏼😊

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yum, yum, yum. Great service, cute guy. Checked off all the important boxes. I'll be back.

My family and I ate here on a recent trip to Sister Harbor. We had pizza and salad, and both were very good. The service was friendly, and we had a pleasant outdoor dining experience. I highly recommend Wild Tomato if you are in the mood for pizza!

This wood-fired pizza place is so good!!! We had a cheese/pepperoni and a make your own pizza. Very family friendly place, staff was wonderful, and the food delicious! 5 stars!

Delicious pizza!

Wow, where to begin! honestly impressed this restaurant is so consistently busy considering how awful the quality of the food was. Everything screams SYSCO.
“Wood fired” sure, but all the bread dough and other ingredients came straight from the freezer. I would rather spend my money at a papa John’s or dominos (the ambiance would be the same, trust,) where at least I wouldn’t be lied to about the quality of the food. Service was also abysmal. I understand wanting to turn tables when there are multiple groups waiting but can I not finish my drink after spending $100+ without being stared down by the host and server and not so subtly having items taken one by one from my table 10 minutes after signing the check? Do better lol. And anyone reading this, is promise you’re better off just getting a frozen pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Delicious pizza. Good service. Good prices.

It's funny place with a great selection of wood fired pizzas and the salads are massive and delicious. Salads are best fresh so bring an appetite or friends to share with. Seating indoors or out. Fair prices, good service, pleasant atmosphere. Perfect spot for lunch or dinner.

Fantastic pizza! Reasonably priced considering it’s in a very touristy area. Some of the toppings were interesting but all the pizza we tried was really delicious.