Toppers Pizza

2971 S Chicago Ave, South Milwaukee
(414) 571-1200

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

New Plant Based Boneless Chicken
Triple Pepperonistix Topperstix
Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Oven-Roasted Boneless Wings
Toppers Classic Pizza
Veggie Classic Pizza
Original Topperstix
3-Cheese Garlicstix
Loaded Tater Mac
Large Pep Pizza

Menu

Featured items
Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Mild buffalo ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, applewood smoked bacon, diced buffalo chicken and finished with a drizzle of mild buffalo sauce and ranch.
14" Large Build Your Own Za
Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.
Single Original Topperstix
Our cheesy, buttery and garlicky Topperstix are perfect for sharing... or not. Your secret is safe with us. Your choice of dipping sauce. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Triple Original Topperstix
Our cheesy, buttery and garlicky Topperstix are perfect for sharing... or not. Your secret is safe with us. Your choice of dipping sauce. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Mac N Cheese Pizza
Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, cheddar cheese and 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
12" Medium Build Your Own Za
Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.
Triple Pepperonistix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of diced pepperoni. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Ragin Pepperoni Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, thick-cut spicy pepperoni and diced pepperoni.
Meat Topper Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hand-pinched Italian sausage and applewood smoked bacon.
Old School Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, thick-cut spicy pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage and garlic-roasted tomatoes.
Toppers Classic Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.
Single Baconstix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of applewood smoked bacon. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Veggie Classic Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes and onions.
Mr. Pibb
A refreshing and spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.
Boom Boom Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in boom boom sauce. This sweet, spicy, and garlicky flavor is perfect on wings.
Buffalo Chicken Mac N Cheese Pizza
Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, and topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, diced buffalo chicken, applewood smoked bacon and drizzled with mild buffalo sauce.
Single Cinnamonstix Topperstix
Our craveable dessert stix are made with cinnamon sugar and drizzled with our delicious cream cheese icing.
Smoky BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken, onions, applewood smoked bacon, smoky BBQ sauce topped with pepper jack, mozzarella, and drizzled with more BBQ sauce.
Triple Nachostix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with ground beef, pepper jack, fire-roasted jalapenos, diced tomatoes and nacho cheese drizzle. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella Cheese.
Parmesan Garlic Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.

Build Your Own Za
14" Large Build Your Own Za
Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.
12" Medium Build Your Own Za
Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.
9" Small Build Your Own Za
Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.

Pizza
Ragin Pepperoni Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, thick-cut spicy pepperoni and diced pepperoni.
Loaded Tot-zza Pizza
Ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, tater tots, applewood smoked bacon, green onions and drizzled with nacho cheese.
Toppers Classic Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.
Mac N Cheese Pizza
Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, cheddar cheese and 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Veggie Classic Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes and onions.
Wisconsin Curds N Bacon Pizza
Ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, golden beer-battered cheese curds, applewood smoked bacon, green onions, and drizzled with ranch sauce.
Smoky BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken, onions, applewood smoked bacon, smoky BBQ sauce topped with pepper jack, mozzarella, and drizzled with more BBQ sauce.
MAUI Topper Pizza
Semi-sweet BBQ sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple and applewood smoked bacon.
Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Mild buffalo ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, applewood smoked bacon, diced buffalo chicken and finished with a drizzle of mild buffalo sauce and ranch.
Meat Topper Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hand-pinched Italian sausage and applewood smoked bacon.
VEGAN Pesto Margherita Pizza
Nut- and cheese-free pesto base sauce, smothered in Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella and garlic roasted tomatoes.
Wisconsin Cheesemaker Topper Pizza
Developed in partnership with award winning Cheesemakers at Cedar Valley Cheese, this recipe features 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella, pepper jack, asiago, and smoked gouda. Try it with hand-pinched sausage and Applewood smoked bacon!
Old School Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Homemade pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, thick-cut spicy pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage and garlic-roasted tomatoes.
Buffalo Chicken Mac N Cheese Pizza
Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, and topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, diced buffalo chicken, applewood smoked bacon and drizzled with mild buffalo sauce.
Chicken Alfredo Cheesemaker Pizza
White sauce topped with our 4-cheese Wisconsin cheesemaker blend, grilled chicken, diced tomatoes, mushrooms and Applewood smoked bacon.
CAULIPOWER?? King Pizza
Our homemade pizza sauce, smothered in 100% Wisconsin mozzarella and pepper jack cheeses, topped with loads of pepperoni and hand-pinched sausage, on top of an award-winning gluten-free, 12" cauliflower crust made by the experts at CAULIPOWER??.
VEGAN Buffalo Chicken-less Topper Pizza
Buffalo sauce, topped with Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella, Greenleaf plant-based Chicken, green onions, and drizzled with dairy free ranch.
Italian Beef Topper Pizza
Parmesan garlic sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin Mozzarella cheese, thin sliced Italian beef, giardiniera, and Italian seasoning.

Topperstix
Single Original Topperstix
Our cheesy, buttery and garlicky Topperstix are perfect for sharing... or not. Your secret is safe with us. Your choice of dipping sauce. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Single Pepperonistix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of diced pepperoni. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Triple Nachostix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with ground beef, pepper jack, fire-roasted jalapenos, diced tomatoes and nacho cheese drizzle. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella Cheese.
Triple Original Topperstix
Our cheesy, buttery and garlicky Topperstix are perfect for sharing... or not. Your secret is safe with us. Your choice of dipping sauce. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Single Cinnamonstix Topperstix
Our craveable dessert stix are made with cinnamon sugar and drizzled with our delicious cream cheese icing.
Single Nachostix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with ground beef, pepper jack, fire-roasted jalapenos, diced tomatoes and nacho cheese drizzle. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella Cheese.
Triple Pepperonistix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of diced pepperoni. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Triple Veganstix Topperstix
These cheesy, buttery, and garlicy Topperstix are made with Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella, our homemade vegan friendly garlic sauce, and served with your choice of dippin??? sauces. Try our dairy free ranch!
Single Birthdaystix Topperstix
Our exclusive Birthday Stix are made with cinnamon sugar, drizzled with a generous amount of our delicious cream cheese icing and topped with colorful sprinkles.
Triple Cinnamonstix Topperstix
Our craveable dessert stix are made with cinnamon sugar and drizzled with our delicious cream cheese icing.
Triple Baconstix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of applewood smoked bacon. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Triple 3-Cheese Garlicstix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with roasted garlic, asiago and cheddar cheese. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Single Baconstix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of applewood smoked bacon. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Triple Birthdaystix Topperstix
Our exclusive Birthday Stix are made with cinnamon sugar, drizzled with a generous amount of our delicious cream cheese icing and topped with colorful sprinkles.
Single 3-Cheese Garlicstix Topperstix
Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with roasted garlic, asiago and cheddar cheese. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.
Single Veganstix Topperstix
These cheesy, buttery, and garlicy Topperstix are made with Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella, our homemade vegan friendly garlic sauce, and served with your choice of dippin??? sauces. Try our dairy free ranch!
Single Raspberry Streusel Kringlestix Topperstix
Our version of a classic Wisconsin pastry dessert. Our in-house dough, brushed with butter, dusted with cinnamon and sugar, baked with a raspberry topping and streusel crumble, and finally drizzled with cream cheese icing.
Triple Raspberry Streusel Kringlestix Topperstix
Our version of a classic Wisconsin pastry dessert. Our in-house dough, brushed with butter, dusted with cinnamon and sugar, baked with a raspberry topping and streusel crumble, and finally drizzled with cream cheese icing.
Single Apple Streusel KringleStix Topperstix
Our version of a classic Wisconsin pastry dessert. Our in-house dough, brushed with butter, dusted with cinnamon and sugar, baked with an apple pie topping and streusel crumble, and finally drizzled with cream cheese icing.
Triple Apple Streusel KringleStix Topperstix
Our version of a classic Wisconsin pastry dessert. Our in-house dough, brushed with butter, dusted with cinnamon and sugar, baked with an apple pie topping and streusel crumble, and finally drizzled with cream cheese icing.

Bone-In Wings
Parmesan Garlic Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.
Mild Buffalo Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in mild buffalo sauce. It is sniffles hot, but not tears in your eyes hot.
Boom Boom Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in boom boom sauce. This sweet, spicy, and garlicky flavor is perfect on wings.
Oven-Roasted Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings, oven-roasted, and served sauceless, but not soulless.
Hot Buffalo Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.
Smoky BBQ Bone-In Wings
Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in smoky BBQ sauce. An amazing combination of sweet and smoky.

Boneless Wings
Boom Boom Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in boom boom sauce. This sweet, spicy, and garlicky flavor is perfect on wings.
Parmesan Garlic Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.
Mild Buffalo Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in mild buffalo sauce. It is sniffles hot, but not tears in your eyes hot.
Smoky BBQ Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in smoky BBQ sauce. An amazing combination of sweet and smoky.
Hot Buffalo Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.
Oven-Roasted Boneless Wings
Our tender boneless wings breaded and oven-roasted. Served sauceless, but not soulless.

Frozen Custard Pints
Lava Cake Frozen Custard Pints
A pint of decadent chocolate frozen custard swirled with dark chocolate cake batter and chocolate chunks.
Almost SMores Frozen Custard Pints
A pint of rich vanilla frozen custard swirled with caramel, marshmallow and loaded with dark chocolate chips and graham cracker pieces.
Vintage Vanilla Frozen Custard Pints
A pint of Toppers version of Wisconsin's finest rich frozen vanilla custard. All you need is a spoon.

Plant Based Chicken
Plant-Based Beyond Chicken Tenders Plant Based Chicken
A side of five plant-based breaded chicken tenders made by Greenleaf. Served with your choice of dippin' sauce.

Drinks
Orange Fanta
An iconic orange citrus flavor that is a true fan favorite.
Cherry Coke
The refreshing taste of Coca-Cola, with a cherry twist.
Sprite
A classic, cool lemon-lime flavor, with no caffeine.
Mr. Pibb
A refreshing and spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.
Diet Coke
A distinct and refreshing cola flavor with no sugar or calories.
Coke
A crisp and refreshing cola taste that is familiar to most.
Agua Fresca Mango
Agua Fresca Mango
Agua Fresca Strawberry
Agua Fresca Strawberry
Agua Fresca Hibiscus
Agua Fresca Hibiscus

Dippin Sauces
Ranch
A Smooth and tangy sauce that has become a pizza dipping staple in the Dairyland.
Garlic Sauce
A garlic and salty butter sauce that is great for dipping crust or Topperstix.
Parmesan Garlic
A hardy mix of parmesan, garlic and zest creating a fantastic flavor.
Nacho Cheese
A creamy and flavorful nacho cheese sauce that is Ideal for dipping our famous Topperstix.
Chipotle Ranch
Smooth and tangy ranch with a chipotle twist.
Marinara
A classic tomato based sauce that has been used for dipping since the start of pizza.
Boom Boom Sauce
A garlic chili sauce that produces a mix of sweet and warm heat.
Bleu Cheese
A creamy and flavorful bleu cheese sauce, most commonly paired with our chicken wings.
Sour Cream
A cool and creamy sour cream. Excellent when paired with menu items that contain our fire-roasted jalapenos.
Mild Buffalo
A mild buffalo sauce for those that prefer the flavor without killing taste buds.
Cream Cheese Icing
A rich and creamy cream cheese icing intended to be paired with any of our dessert options.
Dairy-Free Ranch
A smooth and tangy ranch substitute, without the dairy.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+77 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+76 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I've literally been eating Topper's Sticks since the original location opened in town when I was in college. I'm not exactly proud of the skill, but I consider myself a legit connoisseur of Sticks, and the South Milwaukee location is one of the few to do them as well (and reliably) as the original store. They also make a better than average thin crust pizza.
November 2025
Preordered for a school event. They are AWESOME. Everyone was considerate, friendly and engaging. They were capable and reassuring to me that the order was correct ( not like Lil Caesars)
I highly recommend Toppers South Milwaukee. 👏🏽
June 2025
This was the best Toppers on the south side. Service was amazing, food was always as ordered.

The last two times our pizza was burnt. The first one, the pepperoni crumbled like a dry leaf.

Our pizza last week was a bit of a conundrum. There were no toppings, none. There was a LOT of cheese, we couldn't tell if there was sauce on it.

Even tho the pepperoni we ordered was absent, there was a huge puddle of pepperoni colored...
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cousins Subs - 2965 S Chicago Ave
Sandwich Shop
Dunkin' - 3103 S Chicago Ave
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Little Caesars Pizza - Drexel Square, Shopping Center, 3109 S Chicago Ave
Pizza, Fast Food, Chicken Wings

Toppers Pizza

2971 S Chicago Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
(414) 571-1200