Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
$$$ • Steakhouses, Italian, Vegetarian
Hours:
1220 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie
(608) 856-4040
About Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
Customers' Favorites
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Reviews
Share your opinion about Johnny's Italian Steakhouse
Great menu options and our waiter Jim was one of nicest and attentive people. I will certainly be back.
I booked a reservation for party of 6 guests for Mother’s Day @ 6:45p over the phone on May 3, 2025. I was told my reservation was secured, and they had taken my name and phone number down. I called to confirm my reservation this morning (Mother’s Day) and was told perhaps I had the wrong number/redirected to Molene location. I said no, this was for the Peoria location and had previously been told that the evening was fully open and made my reservation. They did not have my...read full review
Simple stated, Incredible
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Sun Prairie Also Viewed
.jpg)
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse is known for its delicious food, with a wide variety of dishes to choose from, including unique options like freshly made omelettes and prime rib. The staff, including servers like Kayla and Alyssa, are commended for their exceptional service, making guests feel welcome from the moment they enter. The restaurant's atmosphere is described as unique and perfect for special occasions, such as birthdays or Mother's Day. The ambiance is business casual, making it suitable for both celebrations and casual dining. The food portions are about right—large enough to satisfy without going home hungry—and the service is quick. The menu features high-end options, and the food is generally well-prepared, with some dishes like filet tips stroganoff receiving praise for the sauce and pasta, although the filet tips can sometimes be a bit tough and grissly. Drinks are well-made and fancy, adding to the enjoyable experience. The restaurant is also praised for its efficient service, with one server handling a large group gracefully and ensuring no orders are messed up. Desserts, including house-made options like limoncello cake, add a sweet finish to the meal, though some desserts may be a bit dry. Overall, Johnny's is highly recommended for those seeking a fancy and enjoyable dining experience, whether for celebrations or casual dinners.