Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

N65W24838 Main St, Sussex
(262) 246-4949

Recent Reviews

Andy Husting

Best Papa Murphys location out there. Great pizza great staff and the best manager for the store.Kid-friendliness: Best staff out there. Especially the Tuesdays morning crew.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza with Dipping Sauce

Ben K

Very few things in life are consistent, but the food from Papa Murphy's is one of them.The people working here are hard working and polite, and I've never had to worry about a bad order or mistakes. Order, pick up, enjoy.Great work, guys.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory

This place is dirty . Food and trash on the floor and under the food bench. I hate to see the mess in the back. What a pig pen.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Paul Cellphone

Order, pick up, take out the next best thing to a propper Ma and Pa Italian restaurant pizza. Don't forget the garlic bread!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Papa's Favorite, Cowboy, Murphy's Combo

Johnny O

Outstanding quality

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza with Dipping Sauce

Emily VandenHeuvel

Wonderful Papa Murphy's location! Went in during a dinner time rush expecting the service to be a bit slower, but it was quicker than anticipated without placing an order online which was great.

Tracy Ostler

Great service and great pizza! Staff is friendly and professional. Would highly recommend!

Kathy Smith

there $10 Tuesday is a great deal for a pan pizza. we prefer baking at home vs cold pizza deliverd.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

HockeyMa26

Closed the door over an our early & wouldn’t open the door and give my son’s the pizza we already paid for!!! So my son called her. She was looking right at him when he was at the door & said, “I credited your money back.” Let’s start with, no I did NOT get my money back!!! They still owe me $28.35! Not to mention, it’s a take & bake place. My order should have already been done. She could have opened the door & handed my son the “ ALREADY PAID FOR” pizza. Barring an emergency with this employee, this is really poor service!!!

Andy M.

The pizza here is an amazingly good, especially since you cook it yourself. I like this location, too. The staff are friendly, the pizza is timely, and it's kind of fun to make your own, even if they do the Lionshare of the work.

Ava Buchholz

One of the cashiers meowed at me and made me feel welcome.

Melissa McNeely

Constantly closing due to staff shortages but continues to take online orders, so you show up expecting pizza only to find a locked door.

Alayna Ostler

Papa Murphy’s is my absolute favorite place to go for pizza! The staff here is always nice and efficient and the food is delicious. I would definitely recommend going here!

Josh G.

They are not open, even though Papa Murphy's website still says they are. There are no lights on at night and no cars outside. Don't order online. No answers on the phone and you won't even get an automated message. They need to update the website. It's closed.

K M.

They appear to be closed. Papa Murphy website will accept online orders and charge credit card for this location but it will not be open during confirmed time within normal operating hours. No message on answering machine. No calls returned. No refunds given by corporate. If they ever return, I'll update this

Load More

Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza

N65W24838 Main St, Sussex, WI 53089
(262) 246-4949