You're own slice of Sicily right in Sussex. Authentic Italian food made from scratch, genuine service, and outstanding quality in everything on the menu.
Been coming here for over 10 years anytime im in the neighborhood
jeff freed
Good pizza
Elizabeth Koehn
Why have posted hours if you’re not going to adhere to them?! You lost multiple customers by closing early tonight. 🙄
Scott Detweiler
Best pizza in town! Not cheap, but if price is your concern over quality, just buy a frozen one from the store. They took 7th place nationally for pizza sauce, so give it a try. They make fresh pesto!
Hopcobra
I love the pizzas. The cheesy garlic bread so delicious and the mozzarella sticks my kids a favor.
Gary Anderson
Best Pizza in Town .
Jennifer Elizabeth
I moved here from NC..this place looks so cute and you feel like your in Italy..the smell is sooo yummy. I ordered the extra sauce extra cheese on a NY crust..these mozzarella sticks are the best I have ever had. The pizza is sooo good!!!!
Peter Stoeger
Great pizza. Dine in now has beer and wine available. The other menu items are also great.
They don’t have the meatballs sliders on the menu anymore? My dad also wanted a calzone but settled for the new pizza muffins. The Ceasar salad was good. I think they changed the menu sadly.
We LOVE this restaurant! Tony Maronni’s has the best pizza in town. They are a family business that we love to support. They have a loyalty and coupon system that makes the pizza affordable. Overall, Tony Maronni’s is a great spot!
Rachel Lippert
Meat lovers is DELICIOUS and it was ready for pick up right on time!
Parking: Very easy
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily McMurray
This pizza is so delicious - perfect seasonings, perfect cheese, sauce, toppings, and crispy crust. The bruschetta bread is AMAZING. Any of their appetizers are great. BEST tiramasu as well! I crave Tony's every week! (I've heard they used to make a big mac pizza, I think that should make a comeback!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelly Cox
Every order has ben spot on and delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Mackman, MBA, MHA
Our family has done take out with Tony Maronni's several times. The pizza is always very good, and the staff is always very helpful. Never had a problem finding parking. If you're a nostalgic person, like me, you'll enjoy that they have an old school Pac-Man video game cabinet right in the main lobby. While we have always done takeout, they have a dining room so that you can bring the whole family. Glad to have them here in the community.
Parking: There's a parking lot right next to the restaurant, so parking is not a problem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Famous Garlic Bread, Caprese Salad, Cheese Pizza
You're own slice of Sicily right in Sussex. Authentic Italian food made from scratch, genuine service, and outstanding quality in everything on the menu.
Been coming here for over 10 years anytime im in the neighborhood
Good pizza
Why have posted hours if you’re not going to adhere to them?! You lost multiple customers by closing early tonight. 🙄
Best pizza in town! Not cheap, but if price is your concern over quality, just buy a frozen one from the store. They took 7th place nationally for pizza sauce, so give it a try. They make fresh pesto!
I love the pizzas. The cheesy garlic bread so delicious and the mozzarella sticks my kids a favor.
Best Pizza in Town .
I moved here from NC..this place looks so cute and you feel like your in Italy..the smell is sooo yummy. I ordered the extra sauce extra cheese on a NY crust..these mozzarella sticks are the best I have ever had. The pizza is sooo good!!!!
Great pizza. Dine in now has beer and wine available. The other menu items are also great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Farmers Market Pizza, Bruschetta Bread
They have the best pizza in the area. Always hot and devious. Staff is always friendly. Recommend to try it out . Will not disappoint.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Famous Garlic Bread, Cheese Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Sticks, Pepperoni Pizza
They don’t have the meatballs sliders on the menu anymore? My dad also wanted a calzone but settled for the new pizza muffins. The Ceasar salad was good. I think they changed the menu sadly.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
We LOVE this restaurant! Tony Maronni’s has the best pizza in town. They are a family business that we love to support. They have a loyalty and coupon system that makes the pizza affordable. Overall, Tony Maronni’s is a great spot!
Meat lovers is DELICIOUS and it was ready for pick up right on time!
Parking: Very easy
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizza is so delicious - perfect seasonings, perfect cheese, sauce, toppings, and crispy crust. The bruschetta bread is AMAZING. Any of their appetizers are great. BEST tiramasu as well! I crave Tony's every week! (I've heard they used to make a big mac pizza, I think that should make a comeback!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every order has ben spot on and delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our family has done take out with Tony Maronni's several times. The pizza is always very good, and the staff is always very helpful. Never had a problem finding parking. If you're a nostalgic person, like me, you'll enjoy that they have an old school Pac-Man video game cabinet right in the main lobby. While we have always done takeout, they have a dining room so that you can bring the whole family. Glad to have them here in the community.
Parking: There's a parking lot right next to the restaurant, so parking is not a problem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tony's Famous Garlic Bread, Caprese Salad, Cheese Pizza
Loading...