Tally's Tap & Eatery
S31W24661 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha
(262) 446-3153
Customers' Favorites
Beer Cheese Tally Fries
Pizza Stuffed Pretzel
Pork Carnitas Nachos
Haystack Onion Rings
Pretzel of the Week
Traditional Wings
Chicken Tenders
Friday Fish Fry
Boneless Wings
Pizza Pretzel
Menu
Photos
+39 photos
+38 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Amazing customer service! Sometimes the servers are slow but the owners truly truly care and they are amazing people. Just got to keep in mind that they get swamped in there! Wings are amazing! Pretzels are amazing! Reuben rolls are amazing! Salads are huge!! Will always support this locally owned business
Highly recommend the Tally fries!! Great place for a bite off campus. Was good variety on menu! Our group had jerk chicken wrap, shrimp, perch, burger, and bruschetta chicken sandwich. Fun drinks!
Great food, tremendous service. Was immediately greeted at the for quick seating. We stopped for lunch. Our order arrived less than 10 minutes later.
Chicken tenders were extremely tender and hot out of the grill. Fries were more of a wedge style and good. The burger was cooked correctly to medium rare as requested.
Prices were in the correct range. We left satiated and happy.
Parking: Do not park on the East East side...
Chicken tenders were extremely tender and hot out of the grill. Fries were more of a wedge style and good. The burger was cooked correctly to medium rare as requested.
Prices were in the correct range. We left satiated and happy.
Parking: Do not park on the East East side...
You May Also Like
Sunset Family Restaurant - 535 W Sunset Dr
![]()
Family, Greek, American, Vegetarian
Cousins Subs - 530 W Sunset Dr
![]()
Sandwich Shop
Jet's Pizza - 530 W Sunset Dr STE D
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian