Secret Sandwich Society

Name: Secret Sandwich Society
Address: 103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville, West Virginia, 25840, US
Telephone: (304) 574-4777
Price range: $
Rating: 4.4

$ • Sandwich Shops, Burgers, Bars

Hours:
103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville
(304) 574-4777

Menu Order Online

About Secret Sandwich Society

The Secret Sandwich Society is a cozy restaurant known for its delicious food and friendly atmosphere. It offers indoor seating as well as an outdoor patio where customers can order at a window. The indoor area is comfortable, and the servers are attentive, often offering helpful recommendations from the menu. The restaurant features homemade pickles that are more cucumber-y and enjoyed even by those who usually don’t like pickles, along with a highly recommended key lime pie.

Popular menu items include the Eisenhower Sandwich, Rose Marie sandwich, and local beers. Portions are generous, and the food is flavorful, leaving guests satisfied. The atmosphere is pleasant and not loud, with outdoor seating that adds to the comfort. Although service can sometimes be slow, with staff taking time to chat and laugh while customers wait, the tasty food and cozy environment make it a favorite spot. It is close to downtown Fayetteville, making it a convenient stop for travelers. The attentive staff, delicious offerings, and welcoming environment make the Secret Sandwich Society a must-visit for anyone in the area.