15 Best American Restaurants in Sheridan

“First time going in…. Delicious! Friendly. Clean. I had a rice bowl as I have food allergies and was very very impressed! Highly recommend.“

“Love their food!! Wonderful atmosphere and the staff are always smiling and quick on their feet.. 5 star food and carryout“

“Great food. Great entertainment. Fun atmosphere 👍🏼“

“Our family recently had the pleasure of dining at the OutLaw Diner & Grill during our visit to Sheridan. As Wisconsinites, we're no strangers to American food, but this restaurant truly brought a unique Western flair to our dining experience.The moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm smiles and friendly service. The rustic decor and cowboy-themed artwork really set the stage for an authentic Wild West atmosphere. It felt like we were stepping back in time, and that was part of the charm.We started our meal with the Chili Cowboy Nachos, and they were deliciously satisfying! The nachos were piled high with perfectly seasoned chili, melted cheese, and all the classic fixings. Our kids, who can sometimes be picky eaters, loved it just as much as we did.For our main courses, we couldn't resist trying their famous Wyoming Bison Burger and BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich. The bison burger was cooked to perfection, juicy and flavorful, and the pulled pork was tender and smoky. We couldn't help but notice the generous portion sizes; we all left with our bellies full and satisfied.The OutLaw Diner & Grill offers an impressive selection of local craft beers, and our adult family members thoroughly enjoyed the refreshing options on tap. Our server was knowledgeable and helped us choose the perfect beer to complement our meals.What really made our visit special, besides the tasty food, was the hospitality of the staff. They made us feel right at home, sharing stories about Big Horn and the surrounding area. It's clear that they take pride in their community and their restaurant, and it made our dining experience even more memorable.We're giving the OutLaw Diner & Grill four stars instead of five because the wait time for our food was a bit longer than expected. However, in hindsight, we realized that the quality of the food and the friendly atmosphere more than made up for it. After all, we were on vacation and in no rush.Overall, the OutLaw Diner & Grill provided us with a true taste of Wyoming's Wild West charm, making our visit to Big Horn even more unforgettable. If you're ever in the area and looking for a restaurant that combines great food, friendly service, and a unique Western ambiance, this place is worth a visit!“

“Gorgeous restaurant in downtown Sheridan. Cocktails are superb and the food was delicious. Sheridan is a beautiful town and this restaurant is commensurate with that. If you’re looking for a slightly upscale restaurant to grab a good meal and have a good cocktail in Sheridan, I highly recommend.“

“We had a chance to experience the new Open Range bar & grill at the Historic Sheridan Inn. It was the best ribeye I’ve had in a long time. The shrimp cocktail was the best we’ve EVERY had. Sides we huge and the dessert of raspberry vanilla crème brûlée was top notch. The service was exactly what you would expect for this level of restaurant. Server was awesome and the Chef actually brought our food and cleared our main course to make sure it was to our liking. We will definitely be back on our next trip to the Rocky Mountain leather trade show.“

“Ok, food was good, as usual for a subway but I had to take a minute to call out Brenden. This guy deserves a raise. The store was packed and the line was growing. He was working solo and handling it with such grace. The lobby was clean and neat. He was carefully and quickly making sandwiches while greeting people as they came in and thanking those of us in line for our patience.“

“Delicious coffee, amazing food and pastries, friendly baristas!“

“Amazing food and wonderful service!!! Highly recommend!!“

“we LOVE this place! Friendly staff, great food and drinks, stylish and comfortable atmosphere. They also have fun events too!“

“Had the house beef bacon , best bacon I’ve ever had in my life . Will definitely be back . Check these guys out !“

“I had a meal trio a few days ago . Angel was my server, she is pretty new there , My service was excellent she came to my table as soon as i sat down and took my drink order . Brought my drink and took my order very proficient . Brought my order to me and checked on me at least 2 times ., maybe 3 .“

“The Powder Horn Golf Club adds une certaine belle qualité pour notre communauté occidentale florissante et fantastique dans l’État de Cowboy! (The Powder Horn Golf Club adds a certain beautiful quality to our thriving and fantastic Western Community in the Cowboy State!) Plus, besides being a great recreational activity, it is a lovely place to go, being just a few miles to the Bighorn Mountains, for both visitors and residents, to enjoy a day of activity and excitement on a beautiful Golf Course here in the Cowboys state. I highly recommend anyone who plays golf or just enjoys being with friends who like to play or want to learn how to play golf to go out to the Powder Horn Golf Club and learn the sport of golf. It's really enjoyable for a daily form of exercise and enjoyment with your friends and family for both men, women, teenagers and even children wishing to learn the sport. those who are interested just contact the Powder Horn. They will give you all the information that you may need to enjoy the day of golf at their facility.“

“The place is a total dive, old and a little dirty inside, but those places have the BEST food! One of the best pancakes we've ever had. Eggs, hash browns and bacon was delicious. Prices were low compared to other similar places nearby.“

“I was in town for a couple of days and ate at the Pony Grill and Bar two days in a row. Let me just say they have an awesome menu and there's so much more I want to try. Such a good selection of food. I tried two different items on the menu and it was very delicious. I will definitely be back!“