Ice Cream Shops in Afton

“Stopped in this adorable shop on a recent trip. All of the ladies working there were so friendly and helpful. They had a really nice selection of unique items and jewelry. So happy with my purchases and got so many compliments 🙂“

“Love coming here year round! 4 stars, but only because sometimes when you order the hot chocolate they don't put enough cocoa in and its just water with a little chocolate taste, yikes!Sodas are always perfect, and their buttercream cookie is to die for! I love that the cookie is cold!“

“We can’t say enough great things about the team at Shumway Farms! They went above and beyond to provide over 1,000 pints of their absolutely delicious ice cream for our June 2025 Tiffin Rally in Rock Springs, WY—and it was a hit with everyone! From start to finish, their team was professional, responsive, and an absolute pleasure to work with. The ice cream was not only top-quality and full of flavor, but also delivered with the kind of care and hometown pride that made it even sweeter. Thank you, Shumway Farms, for helping make our rally unforgettable. We’re still hearing rave reviews from our attendees—and we look forward to next time! We highly recommend Shumway Farms for any event or gathering—you won’t be disappointed!“