Benny Montanaro's Pizza
CLOSED$ •
About Benny Montanaro's Pizza
Benny Montanaro's Pizza Reviews
103 ratings
Starting in 2023, when we enjoyed this new-ish pizza joint that served ENORMOUS slices (the last 4 of 2023, as we were told) that were DELICIOUS! has now become our annual New Year’s Eve tradition! Love the way we can customize per slice or get a whole 28” pie. So fun to share!! Drive your big car though…
Absolutely spectacular pizza ! I highly recommend!!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank you Benny's for assisting me with my proposal. She said yes!
Benny Montanaro's Pizza is a popular pizza joint known for its enormous slices and delicious offerings. Many visitors enjoy customizing their slices or opting for a whole 28” pie, making it a fun dining experience. The restaurant is perfect for families and friends, providing great food at a reasonable price. While the pizza is consistently praised for its freshness and taste, some diners have expressed concerns about the dine-in experience, noting a lack of service during busy times. Despite this, the pizza is highly recommended, with some claiming it tastes almost identical to New York-style pizza. Overall, Benny Montanaro's Pizza is a must-try destination, especially for those looking to enjoy large portions and a fun atmosphere. Just be prepared for the challenge of transporting a whole pizza if driving in a small car!