12 Best Mexican Restaurants in Casper

Explore Casper's Mexican cuisine gems with Restaurantji's insights. Discover great Mexican food with Taco Plate, Burritos, Birria, and more in town.

Poncho's Mexican Food Mexican • $
3700 CY Ave, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Smothered Green Chili Burrito
Adobada Tacos and Asada Fries
Carne Asada or Carnitas
Bacon Breakfast Burrito
Carne Asada Taco Plate
Carne Asada Burrito
Breakfast Burritos
Shredded Beef Taco
Carne Asada Fries
Chimichanga Plate

“Huge portions and delicious food. Almost every burrito I’ve ever had has a random French Fry in it which I found weird but still love if. It’s a lot of food for the price you pay. Besides their huge/delicious breakfast burritos, The Texano burrito is my favorite!“

4.2 Good253 Reviews
Fuzzy's Taco Shop Tex-Mex • $
3243 Talon Dr Suite 400, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Chips Salsa and Nacho Cheese
Tortilla Chips and Salsa
Shredded Brisket Burrito
Shredded Chicken Burrito
Classic Frozen Margarita
Shredded Chicken Salad
Margarita Shrimp Taco
California Heat Taco
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Grilled Shrimp Taco

“Great margaritas, but.... food came out as if it was in the fridge, Cold... and when we let them know, they took it back and microwaved all of it, now steak was grizzly and tough, rice was hard, these were burritos! Menu's are all crossed out with marker due to changing the food up. Tacky move for what use to be a great place to eat. Price went up.... food quality went down. Shameful, u have some really hard working servers, they try to have pride. John should review his quality in his business, not how much money he is making......“

4.2 Good175 Reviews
Derby Club Gaming Parlor and Restaurant - Casper Bar & Grill • $$
739 N Center St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Mousse Banana Cake
Crab Street Tacos
Poblano Queso
Gnocchi Soup
Club Sandwich
Wedge Salad
French Dip
Chef Salad
Hamburger
Nachos

“I really enjoy this place. Great people who seem to care about the players. They are happy to answer questions to. The only issue I noticed was wait time for someone to come to the drink counter but I understand it's one person running drinks to the whole place. And we won a bit so that was exciting!“

4.4 Superb62 Reviews
La Costa Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $$
1600 E 2nd St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Deluxe Enchilada Verde Rice and Beans
Free Chips and Dips While Dinning
Chicken Chimichanga with a Tamale
Sizzling Steak Fajitas
Fajita Burrito Steak
Chimichanga Del Mar
Fajita Quesadilla
Burrito Colorado
Burrito Rice And
Steak Ranchero

“Food was outstanding! Ordered the Chimichanga small plate and added a couple of beef tacos, all were excellent! Other person in my party ordered chicken fajitas and indicated they were some of the best they ever had. Highly recommend this place!“

4.2 Good78 Reviews
Poncho's Mexican Food Mexican •
776 CY Ave, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada or Carnitas Chimichanga
Steak & Eggs Breakfast Burrito
Carne Asada Fries Burrito
2 Shredded Beef Burritos
Pancho's Burrito
Adobada Burrito
Fish Taco

“Order to drive through is a bit hard to understand. The cashier due to a thick accent but he understood us and had the food ready. Just as soon as he collected the money and we left to go eat our food which was delicious. Definitely worth the “

4.4 Superb30 Reviews
Don Juan Méxican Restaurant Mexican • $
144 S Center St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Chips and Salsa
Shrimp Fajitas
Carnitas Taco
Chile Relleno
Chimichanga
Enchilada
Flautas
Burrito

“This was actually our second choice which has now become our first choice. We arrived for a late lunch. We were seated and served right away, granted we arrived after the lunch rush. I had the chili relleno plate. I do prefer my chili relleno crispy but this one reminded me of how grandma used to make it. The chili itself was good size with good flavor and they did not skimp on the cheese. The refried beans and the rice were pretty good. My husband had the carnitas. I did not hear any complaints and his plate was empty. Oh my gosh! the corn tortillas are homemade, this was a pleasant surprise. They do have alcohol, I had the michelada, which was delicious on a hot July day. I recommend this restaurant. Food and service spot on.“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
La Cocina - A Mexican Concept Mexican • $$
4110 Centennial Hills Blvd, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Taco and Enchilada with Rice and Beans
Pepper Jack Spring Rolls
Chicken Quesadilla
Shrimp Street Taco
Fajita Combination
Chicken Enchilada
Chips and Salsa
Chili Rellenos
Chips & Salsa
Street Tacos

“This little restaurant always lands on its feet! It's newest location is sublime and makes Casper feel just a tad more shiny. Same great people running it with the same great food. The bar is great too.Vegetarian options: Could improve here“

4 Good73 Reviews
El Burro Loco Casper wy Mexican • $$
2333 E Yellowstone Hwy, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Fri Sat Special Quesabirria Tray
Quesabirria Pizza
Chips and Salsa
Taco Plate
Taco Tray
Burritos

“This place is the real deal. Passing through, but live in Texas so I have a fairly high standard for Mexican food. Saving this in my maps for the next time I'm in Casper. I was lucky enough to stumble upon it on the weekend so I was able to have the birria chilaquiles. It was a HUGE plate of food for a very reasonable (cheap compared to home) price. It was DELICIOUS! I can't stop thinking about it. Now I want to go back and try one of the tortas, but a 15 hour drive is a long way to go for a torta ;) .“

3.9 Good73 Reviews
Taco Time Mexican • $
1215 S Beverly St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Green Chili Pork Burrito
Crisp Pinto Bean Burrito
Sweet Pork Burrito
Crisp Meat Burrito
Big Juan Burrito
Cherry Empanada
Chimichanga
Green Sauce
Soft Taco
Crisp Taco

“Looking for good Mexican fast food; Taco Time had good reviews. Got the Big Juan burrito combo with stuffed Mexican fries and drink. Didn't realize until I read menu online, choice of beef, chicken or pork. In spite of no meat; really a delicious fresh burrito. The Mexican fries (hash brown nuggets), that had cheese stuffed inside. Wow, great flavor. Worth going back for. Great customer service as well.“

3.8 Good160 Reviews
Guadalajara Restaurant Casper Mexican • $$
3350 CY Ave, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Tostada de Ceviche de Camaron
Chicken or Beef Fajitas
Chips Salsa and Beans
Deep Fried Ice Cream
Taco Enchilada Combo
Camarones Ahogados
Ceviche Mixto Pulpo
Camarones Al Mojo
Deluxe Burrito
Enchilada Trio

“We stopped here for lunch on 8/12/23 visiting from out of town.The service was extremely fast, very friendly, and requests were taken care of immediately.The food was delicious and steaming hot. Tons of menu choices. The portions were huge, if you are a light eater you could easily share an entree.A free dessert appeared with the check.The ambiance is great, the place is decorated nicely. A fun look and feel (see my added photos).At the time of our visit this restaurant has a 4.3 rating. Don't let it fool you, this should be a 4.7-4.9 rating.As far as dine in Mexican food restaurants go, this is about as good as it gets. So nice to find gems like this. Highly recommend.Kid-friendliness: Great place for kids. Fun look and feel and my kid and others around us loved it.“

3.8 Good76 Reviews
Tacos Mexico Mexican • $
2117 E 12th St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Habanero Chicken Salad with Green Chili
Hibiscus Flower Aguas Frescas
Chihuahua Style Tacos
Chips and Salsa
Carnitas Torta
Shrimp Tacos
Tamale Plate
Enchiladas
Fish Tacos

“Probably the best Mexican food in Casper. I’m pretty sure I’ve eaten at all of the Mexican restaurants including the new ones and the service is usually on par or a little better but the quality of the food the taste, and the flavor is never a disappointment. This is good food there green chili is just spicy enough to make you sweat. Kudos to tacos, Mexico.“

3.8 Good63 Reviews
Taco John's Fast Food • $
80 W F St, Casper

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Donut Bites
Taco Bravo
Tater Tots

“This is my second time trying Taco Johns and loved the chicken street tacos. I appreciated how friendly Jerome was taking our order and the patience he had while I figured out what I wanted. When we pulled up to the window he greeted us with a genuine smile and had our food ready to go!“

3.7 Good42 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More Cuisines In Casper

map Map