Millstone Pizza Company & Brewery

PTL that they had Cholula available.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Stopped in September 12, 2022

September 2022 went with the Colorado Family to Milestone Brewery, Old Trail Town, Buffalo Bill Center, and Buffalo Bill Dam on are way trip in Cody Wyoming #wyoming #brewery #travel #daytrip #beer #food #nature

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza was good. The server was definitely not interested in helping us. We waited to be seated for about 10 minutes until she finally decided we weren't going anywhere. Finally sat us. The folks waiting behind us left. She handed us menus and left. We waited again. It was about 815pm., late for supper but it was Friday night...? I can only guess that she was ready to go home...? Took the order and wheeled around and left without a word. So unfriendly. Pizza was good but we will not be back!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

The place is open and set up different from other places I have seen. The waitress was great, They have the best pizza I have tasted. Also, the beer was the best I have had in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ate here with a group with Celiac - thus we normally avoid pizza restaurants. We had read elsewhere that this could be accommodated here, so we gave it a chance.

We are glad we did!

Some of the staff (I don't remember it was the owner, manager, or the specific role) eat a gluten free diet, and the kitchen staff is trained very well.

Not only did we eat safely, it was the best gluten free pizza we have ever been served! Most pizza places serve the same generic food service gluten free crusts. These were hand made, delicious, and all of the toppings were a hit with adults and kids in the group.

Our experience was good enough I wanted to come share the word.

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza was amazing

Food: 5

Service: 5

We didn't order any food so I can't say how that is. We took the kids to play arcade games. Maybe 3 of the games were working. Most of the games were broken. The other ones that were on just stole our tokens. Worst arcade I've ever been to...

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 3

Service terrible.
Waited over half hour place was not busy staff just ignored us.

Service: 1

Great in house made gluten free pizza, friendly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

What a great local spot! Ordered a large pizza, cheesy breadsticks and Italian sub to go, and it did not disappoint! The pizza was cut all the way through. Their homemade ranch is absolutely delicious. The sub was unique and crunchy; lots of meat on the sandwich. A great amount of very tasty food for the price. The staff was very friendly. 10/10 recommend this spot if you’re in Cody and craving a pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Horrible

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We went to a birthday party today at Millstone.everything was a JOKE!!!!!
Downstairs the water was leaking from the foundation on the floor where the tables were. My daughter-in-law slipped in the water and started falling. We got staff and they just put out a wet sign and said that they couldn’t do anything. We switched eating places. Then the token machine was out and they couldn't even get coins to play the machines. We went up stairs and they said only the owner had keys. We waited for 15 to 20 minutes for the owner to come and they had to take tokens out of each machine to put in the token machine. We never had to wait for an owner to come and do that with the old owner. There was 13 machines or more that were out of order. Two machines that the kids were playing were out of tickets we went upstairs 3 times and asked for someone to come down and put tickets I. The machines. No one came down. When I went upstairs again and asked at the front desk on the way down I fell on the last stair and hit the concrete. Everyone had so many tickets and coins left since there was not enough machines to play. After we had cake and presents we asked several times for someone to come down and count out tickets since the ticket counter was out of order also. No one came. We waited for more than one hour to try to cash our tickets in. Then two women walked down the stairs I said “ma’am we need help with tickets and she shut the door she was going into on me. Never said wait a minute. When had also pushed the help button at least ten times. We had small children that wanted to turn on their tickets and were frustrated wanting a toy. So I put the tickets on the counter and decided we would get a couple of small things that they had way more tickets than what they wanted. The general manager came down and started screaming at us saying she was going to call the cops on me saying I was stealing. No one was stealing they had plenty of tickets and we spent over 100.00 on their machines. She said if I didn’t leave she would call the cops and she would not count their tickets or let us get anything. We have always supported Millstone in the past and we got along with the owner and the general manager. This general manager lady was so rude and the service we got was pathetic. It has gone downhill since the new owner took over. We were told that we should have had patience. We were there for 3 hours and waited the last hour for them to come finally downstairs to help us. How do I get ahold of the owner. He should know how bad the basement is being run. Then don’t have birthday parties or an arcade area that is in that bad of shape. No one ever apologized for not coming down to help us for the many,many, many times we asked for help. We got told to have Patience!!! Really we all had patience for 3 hours of HELL!!!

Food: 1

We went to a birthday party today at Millstone.everything was a JOKE!!!!! Downstairs the water was leaking from the foundation on the floor where the tables were. My daughter-in-law slipped in the water and started falling. We got staff and they just put out a wet sign and said that they couldn’t do anything. We switched eating places. Then the token machine was out and they couldn't even get coins to play the machines. We went up stairs and they said only the owner had keys. We waited for 15 to 20 minutes for the owner to come and they had to take tokens out of each machine to put in the token machine. We never had to wait for an owner to come and do that with the old owner. There was 13 machines or more that were out of order. Two machines that the kids were playing were out of tickets we went upstairs 3 times and asked for someone to come down and put tickets I. The machines. No one came down. When I went upstairs again and asked at the front desk on the way down I fell on the last stair and hit the concrete. Everyone had so many tickets and coins left since there was not enough machines to play. After we had cake and presents we asked several times for someone to come down and count out tickets since the ticket counter was out of order also. No one came. We waited for more than one hour to try to cash our tickets in. Then two women walked down the stairs I said “ma’am we need help with tickets and she shut the door she was going into on me. Never said wait a minute. When had also pushed the help button at least ten times. We had small children that wanted to turn on their tickets and were frustrated wanting a toy. So I put the tickets on the counter and decided we would get a couple of small things that they had way more tickets than what they wanted. The general manager came down and started screaming at us saying she was going to call the cops on me saying I was stealing. No one was stealing they had plenty of tickets and we spent over 100.00 on their machines. She said if I didn’t leave she would call the cops and she would not count their tickets or let us get anything. We have always supported Millstone in the past and we got along with the owner and the general manager. This general manager lady was so rude and the service we got was pathetic. It has gone downhill since the new owner took over. We were told that we should have had patience. We were there for 3 hours and waited the last hour for them to come finally downstairs to help us. How do I get ahold of the owner. He should know how bad the basement is being run. Then don’t have birthday parties or an arcade area that is in that bad of shape. No one ever apologized for not coming down to help us for the many,many, many times we asked for help. We got told to have Patience!!! Really we all had patience for 3 hours of HELL!!!

Did online ordering. There was a listing for 15$ med/Gluten-free build your own pizza. It had no check spot for asking for Gluten-free, so assumed it was Gluten-free already. Well got thier, and picked up pizza and it was not. They remade it for me Gluten-free free, but wife stated the pizza sauce was not a normal one and very spicy. She could not eat it.
I got the small BBQ chicken pizza, half the pizza was no sauce or anything, and burnt. Very little toppings on the other half. Cost 23$ with tax. They closed at 9pm, so could not go back. Very disappointed in the food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

We had the Thai pizza and it was outstanding! The Thai sweet chili sauce was perfect. They offer a Huckleberry Mule that is out of this world and their home brewed Left Coast IPA was ice cold and awesome. Friendly staff, great experience.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5