8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sheridan

“The pizza is consistently good, which is not always the case with carry home locations. The staff is friendly and helpful. I would recommend calling your order in ahead of time. There is not much seating if you have to wait. I had three folks ahead of my order (walk-in) orders and 3 pickups. I waited a total of 12 minutes. That is fast service“

“My favorite pizza in town!! So delicious and truly tastes the most fresh!!“

“We have ate here a few of times now, food and service always good!! The gluten free pizza is so good. Some of the best we have had!“

“I I'm new to Sheridan and have had this pizza delivered, and I have to say your pizza is top notch.“

“I was traveling and stopped at the Pizza Hut the first weekend in June. The male manager and his team were amazing. This night that I was there equipment stopped working. The fryer quit working and the pos system continued to freeze. The manager calmly helped the counter person while taking pizzas out and cutting them up. The prep ppl worked making the orders up. It was the most organized chaos I have ever seen. I have worked in food service at every level for 30 years. I would hire this entire crew in a minute. No one complained or made excuses. They worked together and explained that it may be a few minutes longer. Customer service was at its peak.“

“I had the pleasure of dining at Midtown Cafe last week and had an exceptional experience. The vast menu had an array of tempting choices and I selected the chicken and broccoli puff pastry. It was delicious with tender squash, onions, zuchinni, mushrooms and broccoli in a delectable cream sauce served over a flaky puff pastry. Well seasoned, I only had to add a sprinkling of pepper for color. The environment was charming and wait staff attentive and helpful. I surprised myself by consuming everything on my plate, even all of the scrumptious potatoes! I cannot wait to go back and try another dish, highly recommend!“

“I used to come here a while ago and stopped because the service just wasnt great. I recently came back for the $5 large cheese pizza deal and I’m really glad I did.
It honestly feels like a completly different place. The store looks better, they had the promotional flags, the inflatable, and even Caesar Man out front which made it feel fun and inviting.
The staff were really friendly, the crazy bread was amazing, and the pizza was hot and fresh. I’ve started coming back more often now. Whatever changed here, it definetly worked. 5 stars.“

“I was trying to order a large number of pizza's on the website while they had the 50% off online deal and it kept crashing. I called into the local store and Joshua was very helpful and did an awesome job helping me order it on the phone while still honoring the coupon.“