7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eagle River

“I’ve traveled extensively across the United States and tried countless pizzas, but after living in Eagle River for nine years, Great Alaska Pizza Co. will always be my top choice whenever I return to visit. Although many people have come and gone from the store since I was younger, my family has a special connection there—we were well-known among the staff. Each visit brings back a sense of being home, and it’s something we truly cherish.

The food is consistently delicious, and I find myself missing it whenever I have to order from elsewhere. Their Hawaiian pizza with mushrooms is simply unbeatable!“

“The pizza is great everytime I take one home. I had their "Papa Murphys favorite" and it was like a Supreme pizza, I usually don't like those because it seems like the dough in the middle never gets completely done and crispy, well that pizza turned out perfect! Good prep work makes a great pizza!“

“Absolutely a winner! Great wine selection and the food ...oh yes the food is fantastic. The staff is professional and attentive. Water glass is never empty. Our go to wine tasting every Thursday, just can't say enough about the service, food and wine eelection.“

“When Papa John Schnatter started this company, this location was the type of franchise he dreamed about. The pizza and staff were both stellar and this definitely will not be our first visit to this little spot in Eagle River. Whoever was working Sunday night, the 2nd of June, deserves a high five and a raise. Speedy, efficient, and courteous.Thank you for making pizza and movie night that much better!“

“They are good and great and gets things done on time“

“Unfortunately, several items in our order had issues. The burgers were burnt, the fries were soggy, and the chicken strips were dry. The cheese curds were the biggest disappointment — they arrived as one large clump sitting in a pool of brown oil, with no resemblance to actual curds. The pizza was okay, but not enough to make up for the rest of the order. Everything had a strong taste of old fryer oil. I’ve heard mixed reviews about this place, so hopefully this was just an off night.“

“Amazing food and great service. We came with a large group with little notice on a Monday night and they welcomed us with open arms. I sampled most of the Italian dishes and they were large servings and really good. I choose the steak and it was also good and I would’ve given them a top review anyway, However, I had a second visit the next day in search of my lost purse and Andreas (maybe the owner himself) went beyond over and above to help me locate my purse. Like amazing effort that saved me a day of stress that would’ve cost me a nice train trip with my family. My extended family who also lives close by told me later about how much comfort and compassion they have shown my aunt who is recently lost her husband, when she comes in. Places like this don’t exist where I live. Thank you so much for being extraordinary!“