17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Wasilla

“best pizza in the valley hands down. Super fresh ingredients family owned by the nicest people I know who make amazing home made fresh pizza with lots of love and passion“

“I’m so sad that we have not found this place sooner. Even though there were several orders in front of ours, we did not wait long and the food is AMAZING! We will definitely be back.“

“Cadillac Cafe is excellent. They're close to my home and have excellent food and great service. The servers are very nice and always hustling. Danielle is especially sweet and attentive to her customers. A few of my favorite dishes are pizza, burgers, broccoli, and don't forget the desserts! Give Cadillac a try you won't regret it.“

“best pizza in wasilla. good beer too“

“This is still my favorite pizza place over all no matter where I go. From Nevada to Washington, down in Arkansas and up here in Alaska, the pizza is always the same. Same ingredients, same quantities and same delicious quality. This store usually has a longer wait time than any one I've been to but that just tells me they're that popular here. Trying their cheese stuffed crust for the first time and it doesn't look disappointing.“

“Hands down the best subs I've had in a long time!!! Get the pizza dough subs! I got the turkey. Had enough last me dinner and lunch the next day. This will be our regular spot from now on. Forgot locals, lawsons and knick pizza!! They don't even come close to the quality that Tuscana Pizza puts out. They are the real Mom and Pop restaurant.“

“I have been coming to this sicilys location for years. It’s honestly sad that I havnt left a positive review before now. Every time I order or dine in, I have experienced great customer service and conversation with not only the front desk workers but the drivers and waiters. The food is always delicious (I am fond of a stuffed crust double pepperoni pizza with feta cheese and jalapeños, try it) and have enjoyed a variety of all they have to offer. Would definitely recommend for quality pizza and chill vibes. Xoxo“

“So good! The perfect after work dinner! That crust so so great!“

“Wow. What a wonderful experience as a complete whole! Food, atmosphere, and employees were amazing!“

“I am really impressed! Your pizza is excellent. Tried for the first time, and now you will be our go-to pizza place. Delivery was fast (30 min earlier than expected) and your driver was super nice. What a great place! Thanks for being awesome!“

“Trapper was amazing! The food quality is always good Had some issues with our last order but was given an in store credit (to be called in for redemption). Like the rest of the world, I use the app and wasn't excited to call in my order. But happily surprised at how easy it was. He comped us VERY WELL and made the entire process hassle free 🤩“

“I LOVE the service from the Tuesday evening crew. That is my pizza night; and it is ALWAYS ready when said, it is always hot when I arrive ... and my pizzas are always full of yummy deliciousness! The crew is super-friendly, too ... personable and very reliable.“

“The pizza is really good, it taste like it has a hint of rosemary?? I’m not sure but it tastes amazing, definitely a new favorite!“

“Went to have dinner with the family tonight, and the doors are locked with people inside still eating. The posted winter hours on the door say they are open until 9 pm, it's currently 8pm. Tried calling and nobody answered, I guess they just didn't want our buisness.“

“If you’re looking for top-notch pizza that delivers on both taste and value, GAP is the place to go. Their pies are made with fresh ingredients, from the perfectly crisp yet chewy crust to the rich, flavorful sauce and generous toppings. Whether you go for a classic pepperoni, a fully loaded supreme, or a simple but delicious cheese, every bite is a testament to quality, the prices are more than reasonable, making it an excellent choice for families, students, or anyone who wants a satisfying meal without breaking the bank.

Beyond the incredible flavors, GAP also stands out for its outstanding customer service. The staff is always friendly, greeting customers with a smile and making sure orders are accurate and prepared promptly. Even during peak hours, they manage to keep things running smoothly, ensuring that your pizza is hot and ready when you arrive for pickup. If you ever have a special request or dietary preference, they go the extra mile to accommodate, which speaks volumes about their commitment to customer satisfaction.

The convenience of their pickup service is another major plus. Ordering is a breeze, whether you call ahead or use their online system. There’s nothing better than opening a box of piping hot pizza that smells amazing and tastes even better. Whether you’re grabbing a quick dinner after work or picking up for a family gathering, GAP delivers an exceptional experience every time. Highly recommended!“

“Love this place!!! Best in the valley for fine dining and friendly service! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️“

“Nice that they have kept the same old building, which makes eating at or picking up night orders enjoyable. It's always best to keep it original. Food is always great and not like the other pizza that is all the same with a different name. The pizza has that taste of old-school and has kept it tasting the same. People keep the orders coming. A must order for your tast buds.“