New Jersey Pizza Co
$$ • Pizza, Vegetarian, VeganAbout New Jersey Pizza Co
Customers' Favorites
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Vegan Supreme
Bread Sticks
House Salad
New Jersey Pizza Co Reviews
238 ratings
Share your opinion about New Jersey Pizza Co
First time trying after a decade in Flagstaff, I can’t believe what I’ve been missing out on. High quality ingredients, locally sourced and fresh.
Amazing New York style pizza. Thin and crispy with fresh ingredients. Staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. Will definitely be visiting every time I’m in the flagstaff area!
Best pizza I've EVER had.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 9PM |
New Jersey Pizza Co. offers AMAZING pizza, known for being very very good and top quality. Customers praise the great tasting pizza and consistent, friendly service. The restaurant specializes in NJ style (thin foldable) pizza made with fresh and homemade ingredients. The crust, fresh tomatoes, piles of veggies and olives, and fresh basil on top are highly praised. Some customers enjoy substitutions like pineapple or anchovy, adding variety and flavor. The pizza is cooked over real wood fire, which adds to its delicious taste. While there may be a wait of about 50 minutes, the wait is worth it for the authentic flavor. The staff is kind and the ingredients are sourced fantastically, resulting in flavors and crust that many say are the best in town, even better than other well-known places. The small dining area mainly caters to take-out orders, so customers often take their pizza home to enjoy. The vegan pizza with homemade cashew cheese is especially popular and delicious. Though the restaurant can be a bit smoky and smells of cleaning agents, the experience is often made better by the welcoming staff and the promise of a real treat. Even if it takes a little longer, New Jersey Pizza Co. is the place to go for professional and top-quality pizza.