The Sicilian Butcher

9780 W Northern Ave Ste 1100, Peoria
(623) 471-5771

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Pasta and Meatballs
Cured Meat & Cheese Board
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Parm Meatballs
Meatball Ferris Wheel
BYO Craft Meatballs
Nonnas Garlic Bread
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Meatballs
Italian 'Saganaki

Menu

World Pasta Day
Italian Family Feast
2lb dry pasta / 1qt sauce / 8ea meatballs / 4pcs ciabatta bread

Appetizers
Pull Apart Garlic Bread
Noble Bakery bread + whipped garlic butter + grana
Imported Burrata
arugula pesto + balsamic + heirloom tomatoes + basil oil
Calamari Fritti
fried calamari + marinara sauce
Eggplant Parmigiana
lightly fried eggplant + san marzano tomato herb sauce + fresh mozzarella + parmigiano + toast points
Arancini
stuffed with bolognese + grana + english peas + fried golden
Charred Octopus
ceci bean puree + rapini + moroccan olives + potato + celery salad + citrus oil

Pane Cunzatu
Pane Cunzatu
Choose up to 4 Sicilian-Style Bruschettas

Pizza Alla Palla
Margherita Pizza
San Marzano tomato + fresh mozzarella + basil + e.v.o.o.
Pepperoni Pizza
san marzano tomato herb sauce + fresh mozzarella + calabrian honey drizzle
Sicilian Sausage Pizza
san marzano tomato herb sauce + ground sausage + caramelized onions & peppers + fresh mozzarella + calabrian honey
Spicy Vodka & 'Nduja Pizza
spicy vodka sauce + fresh mozzarella

Chef Joey Signature Dishes
Fazzoleti
handkerchief pasta stuffed with three meat ragu + ricotta + fresh mozzarella + parmigiano cream + baked
Chicken Parmigiana Entree
fresh mozzarella + san marzano tomato herb sauce + parmigiano + served with rigatoni + vodka sauce
Jumbo Shrimp & Mussels Fra Diavolo
roasted garlic + blistered tomato + Calabrian chili + saffron + spaghetti
Sicilian New York Strip
herb breaded + chargrilled + sicilian chimichurri
Branzino
pan roasted + arugula + shallot + herb pesto + lemon

Contorni (Sides)
Roasted Potato
cippolini onion + garlic + thyme
Pasta al Forno
three meat ragu + english peas + mozzarella + herb breadcrumbs
Rapini
garlic + calabrian chili + e.v.o.o.

Craft Meatballs
BYO Craft Meatballs
Choose your meatball + Choose your sauce + Choose your bottom
Bucket of Balls
(5) craft meatballs per bucket. Choice of meatball & sauce (no bottom)
Meatball with Sauce
Single MeatballChoose your meatball + Choose your sauce

Focaccia Panini (Sandwiches)
Chicken Parmigiana Panini
chicken cutlet + San Marzano tomato herb sauce + fresh mozzarella + parmigiano
Meatball Panini
Tomaso's famous meatballs + San Marzano tomato herb sauce + fresh mozzarella + basil
Cured Meat Panini
salami + spicy capicola + mortadella + tomato + romaine + red onion + fresh mozzarella + oregano + red wine vinegar
Eggplant Parmigiana Panini
lightly fried eggplant + San Marzano herb sauce + fresh mozzarella + parmigiano

Salads
Caesar Salad
romaine hearts + creamy dressing + grana + parmesan croutons
Roasted Beet & Figs
cypress grove goat cheese + arugula + saba vinaigrette + pistachio dust
Flora's Salad
baby field greens + arugula + heirloom tomatoes + roman artichokes + roasted peppers + sicilian olives + parmigiano + toasted pine nuts + balsamic vinaigrette
Chopped Salad
chopped greens + salami + tomato + ceci beans + caciocavallo cheese + Sicilian olives + oregano vinaigrette

Sicilian Family Platters
Cured Meat & Cheese Board

Drinks
Sanpellegrino® Sparkling 500ml
San Pellegrino mineral water flows from a thermal spring at the foot of a dolomite mountain wall towering above the Brembo River in the Italian Alps.
Sanpellegrino® Limonata
Sanpellegrino® Limonata is the authentic sparkling lemon beverage from Italy that is bursting with sunshine and all the magical moments of a Sicilian summer.
Sanpellegrino® Aranciata Rossa
This authentic premium drink is made from a unique blend of sun-ripened oranges and blood oranges from Italy.
Acqua Panna 16.9oz
Naturally crafted by the Tuscan landscape and bottled at the source, Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water is renowned for its unique taste.
Sanpellegrino® 1L
San Pellegrino mineral water flows from a thermal spring at the foot of a dolomite mountain wall towering above the Brembo River in the Italian Alps.
Press Coffee Cold Brew
Press Coffee has become an Arizona staple among specialty coffee enthusiasts.
Acqua Panna 1L
Naturally crafted by the Tuscan landscape and bottled at the source, Acqua Panna Natural Spring Water is renowned for its unique taste.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+46 photos
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+45 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We had a very interesting and lovely evening here at the Sicilian Butcher! It was our first time in and we absolutely enjoyed ourselves!! Martin was our handsome server, he was great! Thank you Julia in the bakery and Jason the manager made our time so much better!!!
July 2026
I have came here several times for celebrations and the staff goes above and beyond! The service is always fantastic, food is great, and they always gave little goodies at the end. The manager gave us a box of Italian cookies 🍪. I highly recommend this location!!
June 2026
Absolutely amazing! Our server, Julia was so sweet, bubbly, professional and helpful with ordering the most delicious foods! We ordered the garlic bread (which was literally the most amazing bread we have ever had), the Caesar’s salad and we made the custom pasta dishes. The food was phenomenal! The whole experience was over all amazing! We will definitely be back.
June 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Hash Kitchen - 9780 W Northern Ave Ste 1110
Brunch, Burgers, Breakfast, Pet Friendly
The Sicilian Baker - 9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100
Bakery, Pet Friendly
Wildflower - 9824 W Northern Ave Suite 1860
American, New American

The Sicilian Butcher

9780 W Northern Ave Ste 1100, Peoria, AZ 85345
(623) 471-5771