Bennett Bay Bistro

$$ • Bars, Canadian, Gluten-Free

Hours:
494 Arbutus Dr, Mayne Island
(250) 539-3122

Customers' Favorites

Bennett Bay Bistro Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.1 (47)
Restaurantji Rating

Beautiful venue, with big windows opening to a quiet bay featuring an iconic small island. The building certainly embraces the beauty of the surroundings.Our service was good. A small order mix-up was happily and readily fixed, alongside a tiny bonus for the confusion. The service wasn't always the most attentive, but it met my expectations.Out group cumulatively had the Duck Sammy, Seafood Chowder, Beef Dip, Fish and Chips, and Homefried Chicken. A kids menu was available and...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

I really can't fault them for anything. The Brussels sprouts were excellent, already eaten in the photo. I was concerned the coleslaw with the fish and chips would be too sweet but it was really fresh tasting and savoury. View is gorgeous and staff were nice and friendly.

Restaurantji Rating

We have had a place on Mayne for a long time now and we go here almost every time. The food is so good, comforting and always amazing. It’s probably my favourite restaurant. After a long cold dark hike we come here and have an amazing dinner. I’ve noticed people saying the service is slow but for a small town extremely busy restaurant it can get overwhelming, but for my family we’ve never noticed it. This is a huge recommendation for a comfort meal when your power goes out...read full review

More Reviews(73)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 12 - 8PM
Tuesday 12 - 8PM
Wednesday 12 - 8PM
Thursday 12 - 8PM
Friday 12 - 8PM
Saturday 12 - 8PM
Sunday 12 - 8PM
Updated on: