Pizza My Heart
209 Esplanade, Capitola
(831) 475-5714
Customers' Favorites
Mushrooms and Veggies Slice Puzza
Old-School Pepperoni Pizza
Big Sur Slice of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cowell's Combo Pizza
The Classic Pizza
Seasonal Salad
Side of Ranch
Big Sur Pizza
Fountain Soda
Menu
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place was incredible, we were visiting the city, knew nothing about the place but while walking, we kept seeing dozens of people with pizza boxes, after a while we discerned the pizza must be amazing. As we walked towards it, we could see they had their own pizza box garbage rack. It was stacked with boxes. We got our slice and were beyond impressed . We kept thinking about that spot the rest of the trip. We love it!!!
Hands down the best pizza ever! Pepperoni is my favorite. I drove from Olympia Washington to Lake Arrowhead and made sure to stop in Capitola just to get a pizza! My kids grew up on this pizza when I lived in Pleasanton. We spent our summers in Capitola and enjoyed Pizza of my Heart!💕💕💕
Awesome pizza. My family came to visit Capitola and take pictures of the beautiful beach and colorful houses nearby. Pizza My Heart caught our eyes as we were walking around.
We ordered the following:
🏆 Big Sur - it has been the two time world champion best pizza! So we had to try. Indeed there’s a reason why it is a winner
🍍 Maui Wowie - if you love Pineapple pizza / Hawaiian pizza, you Must order this. It’s the best we’ve ever...
We ordered the following:
🏆 Big Sur - it has been the two time world champion best pizza! So we had to try. Indeed there’s a reason why it is a winner
🍍 Maui Wowie - if you love Pineapple pizza / Hawaiian pizza, you Must order this. It’s the best we’ve ever...
You May Also Like
Pete's Capitola - 231 Esplanade #102
![]()
Seafood, Pet Friendly
La Marea Cafe & Pizzeria - 311 Capitola Ave
![]()
Salad, Pizza, Bagels
Castagnola Deli & Café - 201 Monterey Avenue C-D
![]()
Cafe, Pet Friendly, Vegan