Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos
$ • Pizza, Pet Friendly, VegetarianAbout Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos
Customers' Favorites
Cayucos Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Recent Reviews
43 ratings
Share your opinion about Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos
Great spot for a quick, cheap bite by the beach. It would be great if there were a veggie option on the single slice pizzas.
Excellent pie. Great customer service. Great overall experience
Delicious sourdough crust pizza. They obviously use quality ingredients and the prices aren't bad at all for the location. I highly recommend.
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 8PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 12 - 8PM |
| Friday | 12 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Pie In The Sky Pizza in Cayucos is a cozy spot for casual lunch or takeout, serving incredible and delicious pizza. The food is very good and overall impressive, with a high quality product made with care. The crust is repeatedly highlighted as incredible, out of this world, buttery, flaky, and perfectly crispy, light & airy, and chewy, notably as a classic sourdough. The dough is also incredible. Pies have ample cheese, rich and full of flavor fillings, and a white sauce. Specific praised pizzas include the margarita, hot honey, and the seasonal special elote pizza, described as bomb. The half cheese half pep is also recommended, with a suggestion to order a whole pie.
The service is great with super friendly, warm, attentive, and welcoming staff who provide clear communication. The atmosphere feels personal and special. It is a fantastic by-the-slice place and a hidden gem. A note is that toppings can be skimpy, and there can be about an hour wait time, for which a text service is suggested. It is also wished they were open later. Customers do not mind the wait and would definitely be back, recommending the experience.