Casa Maguey

Food is amazing and authentic!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Food is always mouth watering and delicious. Their carne asada tacos has a kick to it which my sister (picky eater) found very satisfying. We'll be coming back for more very soon 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beautiful and clean. The taco lady is so sweet and we love the freshly made tortillas on the spot. Kid friendly. Great servers. All the toppings you would want for the tacos, medudo and pozole. My favorite is the chile verde. We did the weekday buffet. Nice clean restroom. Easy parking in the parking garage. Would come again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We came in specifically for Taco Tuesday and it was phenomenal. Instead of a basic menu special, they set up a full taco bar with fresh, perfectly seasoned meats and all the fixings. The tortillas were handmade, warm, and incredible, and from what we were told they are made by the owner’s mom. You can feel that authenticity in every bite. This is the kind of food that tastes like it came straight from someone’s home kitchen, not a factory.

What made the night even more special was that the owner herself waited on us. Friendly, welcoming, and genuinely proud of her restaurant, which shows in every detail.

Everything about the night was on point, the food, the service, the atmosphere. This is the kind of restaurant you discover and then immediately start planning your next visit.

Taco Tuesday at Casa Maguey is something special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Unfortunately, our experience at Casa Maguey was extremely disappointing. When my boyfriend and I walked in, no one greeted us. We stood at the front door for a few minutes before finally having to stick our heads in just to get someone’s attention.

We were eventually seated outside, given menus, and then completely ignored. Our waiter never returned to take our drink order or check if we were ready to order. After waiting several more minutes, a small group that arrived after us was immediately helped while we continued to be overlooked.

With how slow the restaurant appeared to be, there was absolutely no excuse for this level of neglect. We ended up leaving without ever being served. Very disappointing experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I gifted my mom two brunch vouchers, and she absolutely loved it! She said the food was great, the ambiance was wonderful, and most of all, she loved the service. Her waiter, Antonio, was so personable and always there when needed. We definitely recommend the brunch!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went for breakfast and did the morning brunch. All the food was tasty. Wife had the sausage, didn't like it but other than that little snag the food was good. Had homemade corn tortillas, excellent. Pozole was delicious. Definitely going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The atmosphere here is really nice and we enjoyed just sitting and talking. But everything was also very good! Great service first of all. We had the combo fajitas and they lit em up tableside. Usually don’t go for steak fajitas but these were so good. Shrimp chicken and steak! And plenty of margaritas. Which come out fast btw.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Came here unexpectedly on a Saturday night and wow what a surprise! We live where we have lots of Mexican options so we can picky and this place matches the best (we live in Coachella valley). It’s surprising that it was quiet on a Saturday night (perhaps the atmospheric river kept people inside) but from the appetizers to dinner and service everything exceeded our expectations. Chips were warm crispy and thin and delish! The guacamole was chunky and pleasant. The ceviche could’ve had more fish but pleasant and vegetables were fresh and crisp to the bite. The wet burrito was too much for our 16yo birthday girl. The carnitas were YUMMY, steak fajitas left my wife speechless and they even brought a flan and sang a birthday song for our birthday girl♥️. It was excellent service and care and we felt like family cared for us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always grateful for the enthusiastic hospitality whenever we visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a catering order for about 10ppl here really last minute (less than 2hrs in advance) and this place came through with no mishaps! They were really friendly and helped me load my order into my car and the food was delicious! Everyone in the office loved it. Thank you all so so much!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Menudo needs way more tripe...

The server with red hair needs to do way better Quite literally the slowest service ever and it sucks because I actually liked the tacos we got. The rice is 100% the same one they sell at Costco (I know because I buy it frequently). They seated another table about 15 minutes after us, and those people got their food before our server even came around to take our order or check on us and finished their food before we were even close to getting ours.

It took her 30 minutes just to take our order, and then we waited another 40 minutes for our food. It wasn’t even that busy, and we barely saw her. I’m pretty sure she was just in the back doing nothing. Other tables around us were clearly getting annoyed too. And of course, as soon as we started showing we were frustrated, she finally came out with our food.

She never checked in on us, didn’t offer refills, and we had to ask for extra chips and salsa three times because she kept forgetting. We were so hungry that by the time the food finally came, we’d filled up on chips and didn’t even have an appetite anymore. She didn’t bother asking if we wanted another beer, and it was actually the other servers who refilled our waters.

Just ridiculous. There are several other restaurants in the area that actually care about their customers. After all that, the bill was $70 for three people — for Costco rice, cold chicken, no water refills, and the worst service. Take your money elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

This was one of the strangest dining experiences I’ve ever had.

The food itself was great-hot, fresh, and flavorful-but the service brought the entire experience down to 1 star.

We were a party of 20 with a reservation made days in advance. We arrived at 5:45pm. Our drink orders weren’t taken until 6:00, which was fine as we were still getting settled. But then, things fell apart:
• My glass of wine didn’t arrive until 45 minutes later, while other cocktails trickled out after 30 minutes.
• When I politely asked about my wine, I was treated as if I was being unreasonable.
• Our food order wasn’t taken until almost another 30 minutes later, and only after we flagged down our server. The process felt rushed and careless, with no apologies for the delays.
• Meals arrived in 15–20 minute intervals, so half the table was eating while the rest were still waiting. Staff repeatedly asked people what they had ordered-sometimes 3 or 4 times.
• When we began to express our frustration, the wait staff actually tried to guilt us into not complaining. It was surreal.

By this point, we had been sitting there for two hours with little service, and only then did water finally start being refilled. Suddenly the server was at our table every 10 minutes, which only made the earlier neglect feel worse.

Again, the food itself was excellent, but the service was so disorganized, dismissive, and even guilt-inducing that it completely ruined the experience. I understand staffing issues happen, but this was beyond that—it felt like we were treated as an inconvenience for showing up.

Unfortunately, I cannot see myself returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Excellent service, tacos. We loved taco Tuesday. Prices are low enough to be able to add my beer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5