5th Ave New York Pizza

$ • Pizza

954 Fifth Ave, San Diego
(619) 236-9006


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for 5th Ave New York Pizza

Went out here after the crab spot was closed was a little skeptical at first from the recent bad reviews but just pushed on through ordered a medium pepperoni pizza came out after 10-15 minutes looked like Peter piper pizza but after the first bite it was meh it wasn't the best and it wasn't the worst just meh I feel like it's a good spot after a night of drinking but other than that don't expect more... I do have the say the older lady sitting down staring at us while we eat...read full review

I ordered the vegetarian pizza and a mushroom lasagna. The pizza was too crunchy and tasted over baked.The sauce in the lasagna and pizza tasted the same, like bland tomatoey sauce from a jar. You couldn’t taste anything but tomato in the lasagna. I was so surprised because it was so highly rated, but it was just so bad.Definitely wouldn’t order from this place again

Most HORRIBLE pizza place EVER. IT IS NOT NY style pizza. And the delivery SUCKS. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. SAVE YOUR $$. pizza sauce is overwhelming with basil... like what are you trying to hide with all that basil?? Chewing the crust of ONE slice gave me a headache. NOT TO MENTION... ordered pizza at 5pm... didnt find it placed in front of our door till 7pm. No door bell rung. O wait... AND ordered 2 pizzas, and got only 1. Wow.... what a HORRIBLE experience.

More Reviews(105)


Monday 4 - 11PM
Tuesday 4 - 11PM
Wednesday 4 - 11PM
Thursday 4 - 11PM
Friday 4PM - 2AM
Saturday 2PM - 2AM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.