Extraordinary Desserts

2870 Fourth Ave, San Diego
(619) 294-2132

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Vegan Gluten-Free Aloha Peanut Butter Coconut Cookie

Cheesecake for Two Hula Girl Coconut GF

Lemon Meringue Fresh Berry Devonshire

White Chocolate Raspberry Linzer Torte

Individual Lemon Meringue Cheesecake

Frozen Pink Hot Chocolate a La Mode

Fruited Flowerless Chocolate Cake

Blood Orange Ricotta Cake Slice

Triple Chocolate Mousse Slice

Chocolate Dulce De Leche Cake

1. Prior to placing your order, please call our location in Banker's Hill at 619.294.2132 for today's available flavor selection. 2.Once you are ready to place your order, please specify the flavor chosen in the space provided for special instructions. 3. Enjoy! Your order will arrive to your occasion decorated with fresh flower petals and touches of edible gold leaf. * Please note that we are unable to accommodate custom writing on these cakes or other modifications.

32 oz. Very Vanilla Bean

French style vanilla ice cream with Madagascar vanilla beans.

DOUGH -Simply Chocolate Chip

Brown sugar cookie dough with chunks of Valrhona chocolate in every bite. Makes 10 cookies. Organic all-purpose flour / unsalted butter / brown sugar whole eggs / semi-sweet & bittersweet/ chocolate / baking soda

8" Cake (Serves 10-12 guests)

16 oz. Strawberry Rose Lemonade

Organic lemons /rose syrup / agave/ fresh strawberries/ Sparkling mineral water

1/2 BLT Grilled Cheese & Soup COMBO

1/2 BLT Grilled Cheese with our Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

12 oz. Pink Hot Chocolate

Hot beverage with a hint of strawberry, topped with whipped cream and strawberry white chocolate shavings.

Italian Salami Panini

Molinari aged salami | Mahon cheese | Garlic Aioli | oil & vinegar dressed mixed greens Served on Bread & Cie Levain . . . Our food is prepared on shared equipment which may contain peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, egg and dairy.

Blue Hawaiian

Hawaiian Blue Spriulina / agave / organic almond milk

Charcuterie Board (Serves 2-4)

Served with ciabatta & levain breads / Molinari 6 month aged salami / herbs de provence dry salami / Manchego cheese/ homemade brie torta / Dijon mustard / dill pickle mustard

Picked for you

6" Cake (Serves 6-8 guests)

8" Cake (Serves 10-12 guests)

32 oz. Very Vanilla Bean

French style vanilla ice cream with Madagascar vanilla beans.

16 oz. Strawberry Rose Lemonade

Organic lemons /rose syrup / agave/ fresh strawberries/ Sparkling mineral water

DOUGH -Simply Chocolate Chip

Toasted

Olive Oil Marinated Goat Cheese Bruschetta

Fresh soft goat & Sheep cheese | OliveOil | Garlic & Herbs | Maui Mango Chutney Served on Bread & Cie Ciabatta

Artichoke Truffle Bruschetta

Avocado | Artichoke Truffle Tapenade | Parmesan Cheese Served on Bread & Cie Ciabatta

Smoked Salmon Toast

Cold smoked gravlax style salmon / tzatziki / scallion / chive. Served on Bread & Cie Levain

Mushroom Bruschetta

Roasted mushroom mix | Truffle oil | Fresh herbs Served on Bread & Cie Ciabatta

Dips & Spreads

Old Fashioned Onion Dip (Serves 2)

Served with Sea Salt Kettle Chips, Organic Caramelized White Onions, Sour Cream, Cream Cheese and Cayenne Pepper . . . Our food is prepared on shared equipment which may contain peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, egg and dairy.

Cheese Plates

Charcuterie Board (Serves 2-4)

Served with ciabatta & levain breads / Molinari 6 month aged salami / herbs de provence dry salami / Manchego cheese/ homemade brie torta / Dijon mustard / dill pickle mustard

Panini's + Grilled Cheeses

1/2 BLT Grilled Cheese & Soup COMBO

1/2 BLT Grilled Cheese with our Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

Italian Salami Panini

1/2 Mushroom Melt Grilled Cheese & Soup COMBO

1/2 Mushroom Melt Grilled Cheese with our Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

1/2 Vegetarian BLT Grilled Cheese & Soup COMBO

1/2 Vegetarian BLT Grilled Cheese with our Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

Sides

Sea Salt Kettle Chips (snack size)

SIDE- Hickory Smoked Bacon

SIDE- Avocado

SIDE- Cucumbers

SIDE- Portobello Mushroom

Coffee's + Tea Latte's

12 oz. Iced Vietnamese Coffee

Sweetened condensed milk with a float of espresso

Shaken Matcha Fresca

Ceremonial grade matcha/ Fresh strawberry puree/ Agave/ Organic almond milk

Shaken Cold-Pressed Coffee

Cold pressed coffee

Passion Fruit Matcha Spritzer

Ceremonial grade matcha/ Fresh passion fruit banana puree/ Agave/ Sparkling mineral water

12 oz. Valrhona Chocolate Mocha

Espresso | Valrhona cocoa | dark muscavado sugar | whipped cream

16 oz. Plain Latte- Double shot

16 oz. Hazelnut Latte- Double Shot

16 oz. Vanilla Latte- Double Shot

16 oz. Golden Milk Latte

Tumeric / maca / reishi / goji berry / spices / ginger Made with your choice of Organic almond or coconut milk.

16 oz. Large House Coffee

Full bodied coffee, with beans hand crafted in San Diego by Zumbar.

16 oz. Brown Sugar Oat Milk Latte - Double Shot

Organic espresso/ Small batch brown sugar syrup/ Organic oat milk

Hot Beverages

12 oz. Pink Hot Chocolate

Hot beverage with a hint of strawberry, topped with whipped cream and strawberry white chocolate shavings.

12 oz. Valrhona Hot Cocoa

100% Pure Valrhona cocoa / muscavado sugar / steamed milk / whipped cream

Cold Beverages

16 oz. Strawberry Rose Lemonade

Organic lemons /rose syrup / agave/ fresh strawberries/ Sparkling mineral water

Blue Hawaiian

Hawaiian Blue Spriulina / agave / organic almond milk

Bundaberg Ginger Beer (Non- Alcoholic)

Australian grown ginger and sugar cane. 12.7 fl oz

16 oz. Lemonade

Organic lemons / meyer lemon syrup/ Sparkling mineral water

12 oz. Whole Milk

16 oz. Iced Tea (Black)

Unsweetened English Breakfast

Sparkling Pelligrino

750ml bottle (serves 2)

16 oz. Kiwi Lemonade

Organic lemons & limes / kiwis / simple syrup / sparkling mineral water

Same Day Specialty Cakes

6" Cake (Serves 6-8 guests)

8" Cake (Serves 10-12 guests)

Homemade Ice Cream

32 oz. Very Vanilla Bean

French style vanilla ice cream with Madagascar vanilla beans.

32 oz. Roasted Strawberry Buttermilk

32 oz. Chocolate Chocolate Chip

Cookie Doughs

DOUGH -Simply Chocolate Chip

Sweet Gifts

Cook Book

Recipes for Bold and Sophisticated Desserts by Karen Krasne. Learn from Extraordinary Desserts' chef/owner Karen Krasne how to make Extraordinary cakes that are as delicious to eat as they are beautiful to behold including restaurant favorites like Ivoire Royale, Viking and Tortamisu. Karen brings a fresh and contemporary sensibility to special-occasion cakes in her beautiful book written with Tina Wright. $40.00 each

Tutti Frutti - Travel Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent: Mango, coconut cream, passionflower, sandalwood, ylang ylang, and Tahitian vanilla bean.

Passion Pavlova- Home Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent: Red currant, candied violet, passion fruit, marshmallow, and a touch of rose

Berry Tartelette -Travel Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent: Ripened tart blackberries, brown sugar, and earthy sage

Passion Pavlova- Travel Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent: Red currant, candied violet, passion fruit, marshmallow, and a touch of rose

Tutti Frutti- Home Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent:Mango, coconut cream, passionflower, sandalwood, ylang ylang, and Tahitian vanilla bean

Berry Tartelette- Home Candle

Our candles are inspired by some of our most popular desserts. They are sold individually in both home and travel size, and we can ship them all over the U.S. This offers a unique and delicious way to have a bite of Extraordinary Desserts anywhere, anytime. Scent: Ripened tart blackberries, brown sugar, and earthy sage

Photos

+97 photos

+96 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Ubereats

Doordash

Trycaviar

Heartland

Recent Reviews

Went for the fist time & I couldn't decide all the desserts looked beautiful, so I bought 7 different desserts to share with my kids. None was left, all were very much enjoyed 😉.

November 2025

Amazing place. Totally worth their title “extraordinary “! Cakes are not only amazingly looking but also have perfect taste - just enough sweet, good quality chocolate, fine ricotta. We had master teapot - I must say their loose leaf tea selection is various.
Loved the street seats - the urban street vibe was nice.

Otherwise, I would say it would be nice if they could brew tea with a really hot water, almost boiling. They only have just a bit hot...

November 2025

It's been a long time since I've been back. I used to go to the old location for years and years. Honestly, the old location had much better charm, a more romantic setting, and better dessert and tea selections, so I was worried.

But then I but into that cake and it's exactly as I remember it. Decadent culinary heaven on earth. The tea was amazing as well. The staff was lovely. The area is beautiful and safe. Thank you.

November 2025

More Reviews

Extraordinary Desserts

Customers' Favorites