ParAgon Deli Cafe
CLOSED$ •
About ParAgon Deli Cafe
ParAgon Deli Cafe Reviews
Great service and good food.
If you want a real deli sandwich, made by people who know flavor, this is your place. Not only are these some of the best sandwiches you will find (especially if you come from the Northeast where you expect a deli sandwich a certain way) but this is a family run joint with the kindest people. I love coming here! The Italian and Mufelleta are the best. Cannot recommend enough.
Everything we tried for breakfast was delicious, and we hope to be back to try lunch before our trip is up. Staff was friendly and brought out high chair and extra napkins for the kids who enjoyed their French toast and apple cinnamon oatmeal. We split a croque madame and sausage side. We ordered a crossiant and ended up taking it and leftover French toast togo
ParAgon Deli Cafe is a cozy deli located on Shelter Island, known for its fresh and delicious food along with friendly staff. Popular choices include the clam chowder, carrot cake, sandwiches, and breakfast items like eggs Benedict, which is highly recommended. The cafe also offers a variety of cookies, especially the homemade one with coconut and nuts, praised for being absolutely amazing. Customers often enjoy dining outside at the small bistro tables, and many appreciate the generous portion sizes and reasonable prices. The owner and staff, including Helen, treat guests like family and ensure they leave satisfied. While parking can be a bit tricky, the cafe is a favorite spot for a quick meal or takeout, making it a great place to visit when on Shelter Island.