4 Best Pizza Restaurants in Bayfield

Eepa's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1248 Bayfield Pkwy Box 226, Bayfield

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Cheesesteak

“We were in town for a family event but always choose to get an AirBnb or Vrbo. This was our first time on Mill St. We looked here on Yelp for nearby pizza spots and realized this was a 3 min walk across the street. It's small inside and looks like it's small business/family owned, which we always support. There is a brick oven that immediately intrigued my husband. We ordered 10" pizzas for our teens to go and sat at the bar while we waited. My husband got a local IPA and I just asked for a red wine. The gal gave me a can of "red wine" that I was not expecting. I tried to drink the chilled red wine but I just couldn't. I do t know why I didn't say something when my husband mentioned he could see several bottles of wine they could've poured. I guess in the moment I didn't want to offend the gal's decision to take me so literally with the request for red wine because everyone there is so nice and friendly. We will choose the place we stayed at again and will definitely visit this restaurant again. I'll just be more clear on what I want to drink.“

4.8 Superb53 Reviews
Vallecito Lake Country Market Mexican • $
18071 Co Rd 501, Bayfield

Customers` Favorites

Try Our Blueberry

“The food is amazing! There are tables to sit outside and inside. Very casual and inside a market but don't let that deter you. They have an extensive menu including ice cream, fudge, burgers, burritos, pizza and the best Mexican food in the area. You can even purchase fresh produce and steaks here. Highly recommend Vallecito Lake Country Market.“

4.5 Superb44 Reviews
The Weminuche Woodfire Grill Pizza • $
18044 Co Rd 501, Bayfield

Customers` Favorites

Ribeye Steak and Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Fried Steak Sandwich
Hamburger with Green Chili

“The Weminuche Grill offers a wide variety of options that are all good. This review covers several different visits. We've had pizza, salmon, southwest chicken pita, and various salads. They're all good. I especially like the southwest chicken pita. They also have a full bar. Service can be slow at times but who's in a hurry with that view of the lake and mountains!“

4.1 Good76 Reviews
A J's Pizza Pizza • $$
381 E Colorado Dr #3, Bayfield

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Ham Pepperoni Black Olive and Onion
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Cheesesticks
Cheese Pizza
Hot Wings
Toppings
Philly
Sausage

“The sandwich was huge and delicious. I had the beef sandwich and it had cheese, lettuce and a nice dressing. The bread was nicely toasted and it seemed like it might have been the pizza dough. The staff was very polite and answered my questions.“

4.1 Good36 Reviews
Loading...
map Map