If I could give more stars I would! Food was amazing, staff was amazing and I do want to add that I know Broadmoor employees are held to somewhat higher standards than other establiments but this staff...! You can tell they.....Love what they do and are passionate about making 1858 an experience one won't forget!While every staff member was exceptional, I apologize but don't remember all their names but special shout outs to Karla, Alex, Gabe and Dillon!! You are definitely 5 star!Anyone that complains about 1858, should just stick to Burger King!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Randy Barsch
Great place for some very well thought out Colorado fair. Red trout, Palisade peach chutney and green chili. Nice to relax there after climbing the stairs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ed Mallue Jr.
Great atmosphere. Extremely tasty food. The steak was special. Drinks were good, but could come out faster. Miner detail because the wait staff was excellent. Don’t care for the logistics portion of getting to the restaurant, but Uber/Lift works and the 10-15 min walk is a good calorie burner prior to a good meal. The Broadmor should waive the fee for guests eating dinner. $18 additional fee just to get in the gate seems a bit over the top. We didn’t even get to use all the facilities normally offered with the park entry fee. Work that out please Broadmor.Parking: Comments mentioned above. Not an ideal situation logistically.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kristen Comas
Tracy was our server, she was so kind and attentive. I loved the cozy decor and the food was fantastic! Tomato tortilla soup is a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve
Had to pay additional money just to enter the park. Had to pay more money if I wanted to take an extra shuttle to the top where the restaurant is, because the shuttle that took us to the park dropped us off at the bottom of the mountain. Almost had to pay more money just to get to the venue than I spent at the venue.
Lisa
We loved the restaurant and the yummy Thanksgiving meal. Very honestly, I could not have cooked a tastier holiday meal. The hike ahead of having a nice hot meal was also fabulous. My only beef is paying $18 to get into the park without it being reimbursed by the restaurant. Food is also quite expensive, but for a holiday meal, worth it. Our service was great.
The food was incredible!! Everything was delicious. I ordered the steak, it was so tender and the chimichuri was so flavorful. My fiancé ordered the trout cast iron style, he cleaned his plate. My father ordered the mixed grill, which he so graciously shared a bit of. I HIGHLY recommend this dish, the bison was so juicy and had such great flavor! But the star of the show was the Venison sausage, I am usually not a fan of Venison but this was out of this world good!!!
PeteK
Absolutely amazing expierence with our first visit to this restuarant. The food was excellent and the service provided by our server, Ney was top notch. I'm glad we were able to get in before their close for the season and can't wait to visit again in the Spring when they reopen. Definitely give 1858 a try, you won't be disappointed!
The restaurant itself is wonderful. But having to park at Norris Penrose, take a shuttle to then stand in the cold and buy a $18/person "park pass" (at night even if your only intention is to dine), and an additional $4/person "tram" ticket to get on yet another shuttle to take you to the restaurant is ABSURD. We had to tack on $88 to our bill and 45 minutes "travel time" for these logistics, for a restaurant that's about 5 minutes drive from home. I wish the Broadmoor would reconsider their approach to accessing this special restaurant.
To be by the waterfall while we had lunch was memorable. I only wish the food was better. I had the special of the day which was the patty melt. It was far from what I expected it to be. It was very dry. The food was overpriced. The service was slow but the waiter was nice. It took our food almost an hour to come out and the restaurant wasn't full. If you're coming to visit the falls, skip the restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: There are ramps for those with wheelchairs or other disabilities
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Michael Whitener
Great food, call ahead to get a reservation or do what we did and sit at the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Thompson
Food was average. Service was okay. The 20% automatic service charge for two people was sneaky. The food and service did not merit 20%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Derek South
Went here on a whim. You have to park pretty far away and take a shuttle. There weren't clear instructions on what to do, so getting there was a bit confusing especially the second shuttle you take from the gate up to the restaurant. The service inside was terrific. Our wait was very accommodating to our daughters food allergies. Her chicken was spot on. I had the bison burger and it was burnt to a crisp. If it had been medium it would have been amazing.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating and understanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
SharrieT
Service was slow. Not sure why. Staff were very nice and it wasn't very crowded at all. Food was very good in my opinion. Such a cute rustic style and we looked out at the stream and cliffs.
Temporarily Closed due to COVID-19
If I could give more stars I would! Food was amazing, staff was amazing and I do want to add that I know Broadmoor employees are held to somewhat higher standards than other establiments but this staff...! You can tell they.....Love what they do and are passionate about making 1858 an experience one won't forget!While every staff member was exceptional, I apologize but don't remember all their names but special shout outs to Karla, Alex, Gabe and Dillon!! You are definitely 5 star!Anyone that complains about 1858, should just stick to Burger King!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for some very well thought out Colorado fair. Red trout, Palisade peach chutney and green chili. Nice to relax there after climbing the stairs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere. Extremely tasty food. The steak was special. Drinks were good, but could come out faster. Miner detail because the wait staff was excellent. Don’t care for the logistics portion of getting to the restaurant, but Uber/Lift works and the 10-15 min walk is a good calorie burner prior to a good meal. The Broadmor should waive the fee for guests eating dinner. $18 additional fee just to get in the gate seems a bit over the top. We didn’t even get to use all the facilities normally offered with the park entry fee. Work that out please Broadmor.Parking: Comments mentioned above. Not an ideal situation logistically.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tracy was our server, she was so kind and attentive. I loved the cozy decor and the food was fantastic! Tomato tortilla soup is a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had to pay additional money just to enter the park. Had to pay more money if I wanted to take an extra shuttle to the top where the restaurant is, because the shuttle that took us to the park dropped us off at the bottom of the mountain. Almost had to pay more money just to get to the venue than I spent at the venue.
We loved the restaurant and the yummy Thanksgiving meal. Very honestly, I could not have cooked a tastier holiday meal. The hike ahead of having a nice hot meal was also fabulous. My only beef is paying $18 to get into the park without it being reimbursed by the restaurant. Food is also quite expensive, but for a holiday meal, worth it. Our service was great.
The food was incredible!! Everything was delicious. I ordered the steak, it was so tender and the chimichuri was so flavorful. My fiancé ordered the trout cast iron style, he cleaned his plate. My father ordered the mixed grill, which he so graciously shared a bit of. I HIGHLY recommend this dish, the bison was so juicy and had such great flavor! But the star of the show was the Venison sausage, I am usually not a fan of Venison but this was out of this world good!!!
Absolutely amazing expierence with our first visit to this restuarant. The food was excellent and the service provided by our server, Ney was top notch. I'm glad we were able to get in before their close for the season and can't wait to visit again in the Spring when they reopen. Definitely give 1858 a try, you won't be disappointed!
The restaurant itself is wonderful. But having to park at Norris Penrose, take a shuttle to then stand in the cold and buy a $18/person "park pass" (at night even if your only intention is to dine), and an additional $4/person "tram" ticket to get on yet another shuttle to take you to the restaurant is ABSURD. We had to tack on $88 to our bill and 45 minutes "travel time" for these logistics, for a restaurant that's about 5 minutes drive from home. I wish the Broadmoor would reconsider their approach to accessing this special restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
To be by the waterfall while we had lunch was memorable. I only wish the food was better. I had the special of the day which was the patty melt. It was far from what I expected it to be. It was very dry. The food was overpriced. The service was slow but the waiter was nice. It took our food almost an hour to come out and the restaurant wasn't full. If you're coming to visit the falls, skip the restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: There are ramps for those with wheelchairs or other disabilities
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great food, call ahead to get a reservation or do what we did and sit at the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was average. Service was okay. The 20% automatic service charge for two people was sneaky. The food and service did not merit 20%.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Went here on a whim. You have to park pretty far away and take a shuttle. There weren't clear instructions on what to do, so getting there was a bit confusing especially the second shuttle you take from the gate up to the restaurant. The service inside was terrific. Our wait was very accommodating to our daughters food allergies. Her chicken was spot on. I had the bison burger and it was burnt to a crisp. If it had been medium it would have been amazing.Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating and understanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Service was slow. Not sure why. Staff were very nice and it wasn't very crowded at all. Food was very good in my opinion. Such a cute rustic style and we looked out at the stream and cliffs.