Johnny's New York Pizza
$ • Pizza, Gluten-Free, VegetarianAbout Johnny's New York Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Medium Pepperoni and Meatball Pizza
Half Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Stromboli and Garlic Knots
Create Your Own Calzone
16 Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage & Meatballs
Side Caesar Salad
Original Philly
New York Pizza
Chicken Wings
Johnny's New York Pizza Reviews
315 ratings
Share your opinion about Johnny's New York Pizza
I’ve been coming here for a good long while now and try to tip when ever I can the food is great customer service is always good I really enjoy the slice pizza and the lunch specials best pizza in town and they seem to keep the place really clean so it makes me feel like I can trust the people preparing my food!!
Caleb was very kind when taking orders even helped make great recommendations. We just got some slices as this was just a quick stop! They even sliced it up extra so it’s would be easier for our toddler to eat without us asking! Above and beyond! Cabo cooked up the slices they were so yummy and fresh! You’re missing out of a good NY slice if you don’t stop by and I lived in Jersey for 6 year. Thanks guys! We will be back soon!
If a crust is good, I will eat it. If average, I'll skip the calories. This is a number one crust! A gradual perfection to the edge which has just a little of the right cruch. The move is to get your pizza here and quickly go to Old 121 across the street and have the beer with your perfect crust hot pizza.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Johnny's New York Pizza is a popular neighborhood spot known for its delicious and consistent food. Customers love the pizza, especially the thin crust and flavorful sauce that is sweet and perfect. The garlic knots are always good, and the salads are also enjoyed. Many appreciate the friendly service and the lively atmosphere, which often features sports games on TV. The restaurant is generally clean, although it is small for dining in, and some note limited drink options, with no ice available for soda. The staff has been there since opening, providing reliable service, though occasional new employees may slow things down. Fans from different areas, including Connecticut, praise the food’s good flavor, mentioning that it reminds them of east coast taste. Customers who order through Grub Hub find that the pizza "slaps" and appreciate that it doesn’t cause heartburn like other places. Overall, Johnny's New York Pizza is regarded as a great place to enjoy tasty pizza and support local business, with many recommending it to others.