22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lakewood

“Coming from the northeast, I’m an absolute pizza snob. Pizzeria Lui does not disappoint! Great, chewy crust with bubbles, slightly blackened. Top notch service. Salads are great, but unfortunately are all ready to go, in single use plastic, even when dining in. I’d pay more for compostable containers, or option to bring my own.“

“Amazing pizza, great sandwiches, delicious cocktails!“

“Their gluten free options are outstanding!“

“Food was great, plenty of it, well seasoned, lots of ingredients and lots of option.“

“Nancy the owner was amazing. She makes you feel welcome immediately. The food was fabulous, so good! The veggies were some of the best I’ve ever had. We went there with another couple after a show and we all said the food was delicious. I would definitely recommend this place.“

“Great food even better staff“

“First time eating at Nicolo’s. I always thought It was just pizza pick up place but today we had ravioli filled with (shredded prime rib and carrots) and a beautiful vegetable lasagna. The Alfredo sauce was so delicious and Full of flavor. The marinara had a little kick to it! Definitely bringing the family back for indoor dining!“

“Been going here sense before I can remember, and for good reason. Johnny’s New York Pizza is good in all ways. The garlic knots are never bad, pizza greasy and fresh, chef has been working there since it opened and is super consistent. The atmosphere is great, as they play so many sports games. The costumer service it usually good but rarely you get a new employee and they usually work alone so it can get a little inefficient. Overall great pizza place and recommend to everyone.“

“I placed an order for dinner, but later called and asked that it be prepared earlier due baking time. Staff was friendly and accommodating. They remained friendly and helpful during order pick up. Everything was fresh and we had an enjoyable meal.“

“Just got an order of extra hot Buffalo & Mango Habanero wings. Both were very good and I grew up just south of Buffalo so I'm in the know.“

“Great place, were from New Haven CT. home of pizza and been here for 2 years. Always trying pizza here and this is the best we found so far. Counterman was extremely friendly and knowledgeable. We had a chix parm sub and 2 slices. Chix par was very good, excellent bread, the peperoni slice was very good and the sausage great. Prices are very reasonable. We will be back!!“

“Best restaurant ever! We are having our wedding party here and they have the best staff around. Highly recommend!!!“

“Get a job here and you will get laid I was with my boyfriend for almost a year a.d he started working here and immediately started seeing someone else. Under the guise of,,working late.lying. cheating“

“Wonderful pizza and friendly staff. Their slices are MASSIVE and worth the cost. I did delivery instead of dining in so I can’t speak to the experience in the restaurant itself, but I definitely recommend ordering through their site rather than through food delivery app (Though I did find them originally through an app so I hope they don’t fight that TOO hard!)“

“We had my son and daughter-in-law’s rehearsal dinner at BJ’s in Lakewood. I had to plan this from 1600 miles away but the process was easy and we were able to communicate on all of the details via email. On the day of the event, the manager and staff (Jamilla and David especially) were very accommodating and helpful. Food was great, the drinks were varied and came quickly to our 50+ guests. Thank you so much.“

“Great food and service! Shout out to the manager on Oct 14th—she was so patient and kind while training her staff on a busy Friday night. We had exceptional service from Alex, the young cashier. My 88-year-old dad, who has dementia, was with me, and Alex took the time to chat with him, even when he repeated himself. Such a kind and genuine person—Garramone’s is lucky to have staff like this!“

“Anthony’s Pizza is always great, but Omar’s customer service really stood out. He was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. You can tell he genuinely cares about the customers and the experience. The food was awesome as always, and Omar made the visit even better. Definitely coming back!“

“We had a kids bday party at The Bounce Place and got four pizzas from here. I would recommend ordering as early as possible, it took just a little bit longer than we expected to get the pizzas--this place is in the mall food court so I don't think they're accustomed to getting large orders first thing in the morning like that but overall we were very happy with the experience. The pizzas were tasty and it was extremely convenient to just walk them down the hall into the party.“

“Came in for lunch, GREAT service, great lunch. Im only taking off one star for a pet peeve of mine. Just make sure your windows are clean , especially the front entry. Id do this at least once a day. Shinning windows make a great impression.“

“We always order delivery and have been for years. I have to say this shop has gotten so much better! We usually order pizzas but this time we ordered the “boats” they were huge and well filled! I highly recommend! Try this shop out I think you will be pleasantly impressed“

“Best Pizza in town.Also has many other options for wings,salad and more“