50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sheridan

“My family was in town for a burial of our loved one. We stopped at Pizza Hut after. There was 20 plus of us. The waitress, Kelly, was very accommodating for all of us. She went above and beyond to meet our thirsty requests and arranged the dinner room to fit us all so we could sit together. Our pizza was delicious and fast. Strongly recommend“

“What a super restaurant! Our group of 12 enjoyed a fantastic lunch. Misha ensured we had excellent service. Roof top patio or an absolutely stunning vine covered patio. Food was amazing. Particularly the Shrimp Scampi and Chicken Parmigiana. Located on corner of lovely little town with unique shops. Highly recommend if you are in Denver area.“

“As of my local standards, this place hit all my boxes tonight. A great ratio of timing, and food, most of all. It took much less time than I expected, for how delicious my food was. Got the vodka penne(is it a penne?) And it came out in less that 7 minutes. Fantastic, too. Sauce stuck to the back of my fork well, not quite enough Italian sausage, but if there were any more, it would indeed over-power the other lovely seasonings in it. Nicely done back there! Guarantee the chefs are alright to work with, too. One of the super sweet waitresses came up and complimented my head wrap(thank you, by the way) and seemed like she wasn't coming back from a war zone in the kitchen, so thats great, I know how it can be back there.
If it wasnt a chain, and I could make a meaningful recommendation...Let your vodka sauce carry the Italian sausage, don't purchase or make such a heavily seasoned sausage. I'm sure this a common theme here is your Ingredients clashing with eachother....using the same spices twice without adding any layers of complexity to it. Probably one of the hardest things to get right, I'm sure. Lastly, its alright to be slow with orders! One should not expect you to make a lovely meal within several minutes. You did though, and i was amazed. Cheers, friends! Thank you for feeding me and I genuinely hope all the staff there have great lives!“

“This restaurant(s) is so unique and incredibly sophisticated no matter what venue you are looking for this is the place! The atmosphere is awesome due to the incredible décor, large screen, a multitude of different type of seating, large TV’s located all around the bar! The service and restaurant is second to none! The bartenders are so professional and friendly. Believe it or not we were actually asked if we were satisfied with our drinks! We were politely and professionally served our many food and drink selections! When our pizza slices were served, my mouth dropped, because I have never seen slices of pizza so huge! I have not had a slice of pizza that was so good with just the right amount of tasty toppings on mine! We ordered chicken wings, half naked and half buffalo wing sauce. The chicken wings had been fried to perfection and was so good we could not make up our minds which type of chicken wings was the best, so we called it a pleasingly tie!“

“Coming from the northeast, I’m an absolute pizza snob. Pizzeria Lui does not disappoint! Great, chewy crust with bubbles, slightly blackened. Top notch service. Salads are great, but unfortunately are all ready to go, in single use plastic, even when dining in. I’d pay more for compostable containers, or option to bring my own.“

“It is a very nice place with a unique atmosphere, the decoration, the area, the place, the staff and, above all, the food is excellent and very tasty.I really recommend this place 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Amazing pizza, great sandwiches, delicious cocktails!“

“We had a great time it was girls night out“

“We realized when we got there they were closing soon but host was super nice and welcoming and bar tender reassured us it was no big deal. Pizza was DELICIOUS, absolutely recommend this place. Good food with the nicest friendliest people that work there !!!!“

“Great pizza and excellent staff. Thank you for the best pizza in Denver.“

“My husband discovered this place and told me I had to come and check it out. It did not disappoint!! I’d give it 10 stars if I could. The staff was very nice and the pizza is super delicious! The slices are the perfect size and the garlic knots are soft and slightly chewy! I had the honey sting and it was amazing. I’ll be back to try the arugula pizza!“

“​We had a great experience at Corner House Pizza! The pizza was delicious—the crust was wonderfully flaky without being dry at all. Benjamin took care of us and was an absolute pleasure. We’ll definitely be coming back!“

“Great pizza and wings. Fun for the kids and always wonderful service!“

“my daughter took me here for my birthday lunch yesterday. The food was amazing. Thank you Ella for such wonderful service. The whole staff is great“

“The pizza is about the best“

“If you are planning a trip to Colorado, plan it in August, go to Blue Pan Pizza , and get their August special PEACH pizza. I had it last year and it’s even better than I remember this year! Get that perfect bite and make every one of your tastebuds happy!“

“We wanted Italian, and it was near our hotel. So glad we did. My wife nailed it when she said “this sauce is just what we had in Sicily”. Very helpful staff; we split a small salad, and rather than two plates and do it ourselves, our waitress brought it out on two plates…..darn, I failed to get her name. Next time we are in Denver, this is where we will go.“

“The bartender is great! Very friendly environment.“

“The food, drinks, staff and atmosphere so cool! We will be back for sure.“

“Some amazing pizza! highly recommend grabbing a slice with their root beer!“

“We stopped by for the first time yesterday and had a great experience! Our waiter Nick was very friendly and knowledgeable and gave us great recommendations! We’d come back for him alone (even though he’s an SEC fan hahaha), but the food was phenomenal too! Best pizza in Denver without a doubt! We will be back!“

“Overpriced no taste pizza, bad service, better places to spend your money.“

“Amazing pizza 🍕👌🏻😍 great staff and good ambience! Highly recommend.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza — The Name Says It All! I don’t usually write long reviews, but when a business truly goes above and beyond, they deserve to be recognized — and Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza absolutely does. I ordered two pizzas recently, and one came out a little different from what I had requested. Totally understandable — mistakes happen! But the way this team handled the situation completely blew me away. From the moment I arrived, the manager personally came out to meet me and immediately apologized, even though I told him there was no need to. It was such a small mix-up, but they treated it as an opportunity to make things right and to make sure my experience was nothing short of perfect. You can really tell that everyone at Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza takes pride in what they do. The entire staff is upbeat, kind, and genuinely happy to be there. There’s a contagious positivity in that place — every single person is friendly, professional, and welcoming. It’s rare to find a restaurant that not only makes great food but also makes you feel good being there. Now, let’s talk about the food — because it’s on a whole other level. The pizza alone is hands down the best in Colorado — perfect crust, flavorful sauce, melty cheese, and fresh toppings that taste like they were just picked. But the Italian food? Oh my goodness. It’s absolutely amazing. From the pinwheels to the chicken parm, the Stromboli, spaghetti, and meatballs — every dish is phenomenal. You can taste the care and authenticity in every bite. It’s real, homemade-style Italian comfort food done to perfection. A big shoutout to Carlo, the owner, for building such an incredible team and for training his staff to not just serve food, but to serve an experience. It’s clear that he takes pride in what he’s created — a restaurant where the quality of the food and the quality of the service are equally top-tier. Brooklyn’s Finest Pizza has earned a lifelong customer in me. Between the unbeatable food, the friendly staff, and the exceptional service, this place sets the standard for what every local restaurant should strive to be. If you haven’t tried them yet, do yourself a favor — order a pizza (or two!) and some of their Italian dishes. You’ll see exactly why this place truly lives up to its name. Thanks to the Denver location on Lowell across from Regis.“

“Food was great, plenty of it, well seasoned, lots of ingredients and lots of option.“

“Delicious food, friendly service“

“I am new lover of NY style pizza! crispy tasty crust, all fresh products and cheeses used, and you can tell! The pizza, garlic knots, and create your own stromboli was perfect for our party. The homemade tiramisu was a great finale for the evening. It is so good to support local business with kind and passionate owners that are on the grounds to assist you!“

“10000000 out of 10. Highly recommend it. Try the sexy shi.... Try the one with jalapeno and cream cheese pepperoni. 😍 Pizza was evenly sauced. Toppings were actually really fresh none of that canned jalapenos some other companies have. The staff was super friendly and patient ( I couldn't decide on the slice or beer choice ). They have daily specials. They really got me over here cheesin no pun intended. Sexy doesn't even begin to describe it. Check them out. 2 slice and a bear for about $15 not bad at all. Slices are huge , beer is cold. Atmosphere warm and inviting add the friendly staff, a few beers. Some good not so greasy pizza and you have yourself a well established place . Good job. See you soon. ❤️ From a pizza fanatic“

“Pizza, Wings, Subs and now, Wraps! Great afternoon for Lunch on the patio!“

“We catered Virgilio’s for our January 2023 wedding in Evergreen. Desirae went above and beyond to help us with our order. She was knowledgeable and honest with us and we really enjoyed working with her. The food was amazing as always!“

“The best Eggplant anywhere!!“

“Delicious pizza! Both round and Sicilian“

“If you are planning a trip to Colorado, plan it in August, go to Blue Pan Pizza , and get their August special PEACH pizza. I had it last year and it’s even better than I remember this year! Get that perfect bite and make every one of your tastebuds happy!“

“Their gluten free options are outstanding!“

“We went for lunch or the first time today and had the amazing lunch. We eachhad the lunch special, which includes a specialty Pizza and a salad of your choice for starting at $14.50. I had the funguy Pizza, which is a Mushroom Pizza. It was absolutely amazing. I ordered mine without arugula , as I do not perfer that. It was so good that I ordered a full size to take home for dinner. Our server was Jordan and she was awesome. Very friendly and knowledgeable. The only downside I have to say is that their drinks were just okay. We had a Italian spritzer that was kind of tart, and then I ordered a Vodka martini, which they said they do not commonly make, and I could tell why... I sent it back and ended up getting a glass of red wine but the pinot noir was mediocre at best. I think management should up their Wine selection and quality, if they're going to pair with Italian dishes. I would definitely go back and order more Pizza and the meatballs look amazing as well.“

“DO NOT SUPPORT THIS BUSINESS! THEY CONDONE THE USE OF THE "N" WORD IN THE KITCHEN“

“Nancy the owner was amazing. She makes you feel welcome immediately. The food was fabulous, so good! The veggies were some of the best I’ve ever had. We went there with another couple after a show and we all said the food was delicious. I would definitely recommend this place.“

“Outside Pizza impressed me with their pies! Loving all their fresh ingredients, so perfectly yum! The staff was super friendly and eager to make sure we were happy with our meal. How fun is that food trailer!!“

“Was amazing Joyce is super nice and sweet come check her out !“

“Clean and spacious location... good food... and excellent kindness and courtesy staff... especially Nathan... we will definitely be back and recommend.“

“We love this wonderful spot!!! We especially love Angela who is awesome… and Mario as well!! Food is awesome!!! You can’t go wrong at this special place!“

“This was our first time trying Krave It and we couldn't have gone at a better time. It wasn't busy, so we could look over the menu with ease. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful too! We came in from out of state and had to make a special trip to try them before leaving and I'm telling you it's sooooo worth the stop!! Shared the Truffle Eleven and HAD to buy another to take with me because it was just that good! It was like having a truffle garlic Philly cheese steak with a great cheese pull between a soft garlic knot hoagie roll, PERFECTION! The pizzas were delicious as well and so many unique flavors I wanted to try them all! Highly recommend if you're nearby to get yourself some 🩷“

“Wonderful family run establishment!“

“‘Na Favola is amazing, truly authentic Italian food - just like in Rome! Take my (roman) word for it! Daniele, Silvio and Co: Daje!!!!“

“Better than Lou Malnati’s…Your taste buds will enjoy their hearty sauce, gooey cheese, and the crispy crust. Definitely what was missing in Denver, a true Chicago joint that makes you feel like family!“

“Great food great service go visit all locations“

“My wife has been coming here for almost 26 years. Always stellar service and delicious food. Try the garlic cheese bread.“

“Great pizza cut little diner“

“What a gem…small place with big flavors. The pizza crust is perfect! Great lunch special, I’ll be back!“