5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elizabeth

“If you want to know what real customer service looks like, this is it.

There was an issue with the system that could have easily turned into a frustrating experience, but instead, it became the reason I’ll be a loyal customer for life. Joshua Hicks, the owner, personally stepped in, communicated every step of the way, and made sure my order was delivered directly to me without hesitation. No excuses. No runaround. Just integrity and follow through.

And let’s talk about the food, because even without the incredible service, this is hands down the best pizzeria in town. The crust? Perfectly balanced, crispy on the outside, soft and flavorful inside. The toppings? Generous, fresh, and thoughtfully layered. Every bite tastes like it was made by people who genuinely care about what they’re serving.

Great pizza is one thing. Great leadership is another. When you get both in the same place, that’s rare.“

“Great place to go for great food and great service. If not in the mood for pizza many other things to choose from. Hands down great food.“

“Dinner at our favorite restaurant. Happy New Year's Catalina's Best restaurant in Elizabeth. Great meals. Fantastic foods. Good service. I had my favorite Caesar salad with avocado. So yummy..“

“I wish their delivery area was larger. I order online because there are usually good deals, and I enjoy not talking on the phone. This location seems cleaner than other Domino's that I've gone to.

They don't put the garlic sauce on the crust. Huge disappointment.“

“Well worth the drive to Kiowa from Denver. Excellent food and great service. The Calzones, and Buffalo Ravioli are awesome. The building was amazing once a duplex home, where my Great Grandparents lived after retiring from farming in the 1930s“