Hayley's Ice Cream
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
About Hayley's Ice Cream
Hayley's Ice Cream Reviews
237 ratings
Unfortunately, the shop wasn't open when we arrived at 8:51pm. Tried calling the number at 8:52pm and no one answered (line disconnected after a few minutes). Not even a voicemail. Drove up from Carbondale looking forward to getting some ice cream after dinner and was sorely disappointed. This place was hyped up by my boyfriend who has fond memories of the mexican chocolate. Guess I'll never know. 💔
Excellent flavor choices and great service!
Great milkshakes and fabulous service. The staff was extra kind and went out of their way to make our family very happy!
Hayley's Ice Cream is a popular spot for a sweet treat after a hike. Enjoy delicious ice cream, including cheesecake flavors, and fast service. Be prepared for a possible wait in line, and note that parking can be a challenge. The staff is accommodating, especially for those with allergies. The shop offers a variety of tasty flavors, with large portions at a fair price. It is located near a stream and park, providing a nice place to sit and enjoy the ice cream. The owner is genuinely kind and supports the local community. Visitors can pair their ice cream with fresh-squeezed lemonade while taking in the terrific views. Though some find the cheesecake flavors lackluster, others enjoy flavors like mint chocolate chip and recommend trying the flavor before ordering. Despite some service issues, many customers say it’s the best ice cream in Estes, praising the friendly staff and quality treats.