22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden City

“I've lived here 6 months. When I first moved here, I asked everyone including my neighbors where's the best pizza in here ? They said Empire Pizza !!! Well since then I've never had a bad meal. The food is delicious. The girl that works at the front counter Ella, a very lovely young lady always takes my order and is always sweet and kind and happy. I enjoy fresh ingredients and the hospitality every time I go there and order their food.“

“I am 68 years old, a Colorado Greeley native. I have been eating at Fanta since high school when it was downtown. I love bringing new friends who moved to Greeley into the restaurant. They are always impressed and love the pizza! Best ever Pizza in Greeley!!“

“We ordered Mama Ruth’s for my softball team. They pizza was hot, fresh and tasty. We will definitely order from them again and will stop in when we are in the area.“

“Great food, great service, fun environment! Go check it out! Check out the homemade ice cream!“

“We had amazing service last night at MOD. An employee by the name Joren I believe, helped us out and he asked my partner how she spells her name. Most people just write something down and never spell it right. The whole team seemed to work well together too. It was cool to watch them get through the dinner rush. They also started running out of mozzarella cheese but they made it through the rush. The boss I believe took time to go to the Johnstown location to get more cheese for the night. Above and beyond teamwork, and good service.“

“Great food !Amazing owners! Rock Star staff members!!“

“What an amazing evening we had at Pinocchio Prime! We celebrated my husband’s 60th surprise birthday dinner there, and everything was absolutely perfect. Annie, Cecil, Forest, and the entire staff were outstanding — their service was truly above and beyond. The prime rib was the best we’ve ever had — you simply can’t find it any better! We had such a wonderful time and are so grateful for your incredible hospitality. Thank you for making it a night to remember!“

“Closest to grandma's house we have found!! We will be back!“

“November 23rd, we ordered 3 pizzas & breadsticks around 10 pm, after a great Elvis tribute concert at UCCC. We picked up the food at the 16th Street store, got home, and started eating our Jackpot, Hawaiian & Pepperoni pizzas. It was the absolute best pizza we've had in years! My family has bought pizzas from this location since the late 80s and have NEVER been disappointed.“

“Great Location, employees were friendly and service was fast. They have a crustless option for any of you KETO folks out there. I do miss the free cookie dough option after taking a survey though lol :)
Try the Gourmet Chicken & Garlic...you'll thank me later! Big Murphy Stuffed or the Cowboy are also solid choices.“

“I love Bravos. Get a 14 inch pizza and 2 drinks for $25. My fiance and I go here often. It was the first place we ate after moving to Greeley and we have been back so many times. The pizza is so good and the topping choices are exciting. Their burgers and Philly Cheese are great too“

“Honestly for the amount of younger guys working this place is well maintained and the food is really good. I say that because every other place with younger people around Evans is absolutely terrible. This was my first time in for the 1.25 pepperoni bread rolls and I’ll be back, the food was very fresh and delicious.“

“Great burgers, fast and friendly service!“

“We called to placed an order for pickup and spoke with Coy. The customer service Coy provides is above and beyond the best I've had in a long time. We were greated by Yami and she too was pleasant and positive to work with. It's been a long time since we have eaten a Caroli from Romas but we will be back for more. Our Caroli reminded me from the 90's at the Romas off of Washington, in Thornton. Thanks for the great food! Laura“

“great food and awesome people working“

“Akanes 3 birthday she loves coming and playing with his big brother“

“Stopped in today mid afternoon. A party of about 20 of us. One waitress did everything and she was SUPER. She did a great job. Food was warm, drinks were cold, and she was sporting a smile the whole time. Hope to be back next time we're in the area.“

“Have dined here in the past with great experiences but last night was a bit weird . Nobody waited on us and finally went to the counter to order and was told that a waitress would come over. She never came so went back to counter and the nice but confused girl took our order . And then she went home🤣. So the cook took over and handled things like a professional. There was a girl manning the bar and she had her hands full. The food was great. I assume they were shorthanded so will give them a pass on the lack of service as they handled the stress professionally and with a smile .“

“Because of the FANTASTIC service by Freddy, I am giving this place 5 stars. His service was excellent when I tried to order pizza this past weekend for a family picnic. He was incredible and I would return because of him. He deserves a raise!“

“November 23rd, we ordered 3 pizzas & breadsticks around 10 pm, after a great Elvis tribute concert at UCCC. We picked up the food at the 16th Street store, got home, and started eating our Jackpot, Hawaiian & Pepperoni pizzas. It was the absolute best pizza we've had in years! My family has bought pizzas from this location since the late 80s and have NEVER been disappointed.“

“Extra large cheeseburger pie. One of our favorites. Last purchased on Sunday 10/12/2025. Disappointed with the toppings“