25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Collins

Totally 80's Pizza & Museum Pizza • $
2567 S Shields St Unit 4C, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Yippee Ki Yah Mother Clucker Pizza
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza Small 9
Giant Garlic Parmesan Twists
Totally 80s Supreme Pizza
Flamin' Hot Cheeto Pizza
New Wave Rave Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Specialty Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Jessie's Swirl

“I was excited to try this place but was sketched out by the menu. There are too many options (a very good thing if you're staying and have a big party like we did, so not a complaint!) Tried the pizza with green chili and cream cheese (I don't want to butcher the name) and it was PHENOMENAL. Cheese was so stretchy. It was hot but not a burn the roof of your mouth hot. It was literally perfect. A gorgeous nostalgic stop as well, I might be a 90s kid, but good lord, everything here brought me back to how my mom and dad raised me. I'm definitely coming back if I end up in Fort Collins. (!!Apologies for not moving all the tables back before I left, I was unsure of where some of the tables came from and there was another party where the others were supposed to go and didn't want to intrude!!)“

4.7 Superb262 Reviews
Oregano's Italian • $
4235 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Linguini
The Big Beefstro Salad
El Diablo Shrimp Pasta
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Garlic Cheese Bread
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Alfredo the Dark
Deep Dish Pizza
Hakuna Piccata

“Gosh! My daughter wanted to eat here for her 18th bday and I must say… the staff was amazing and so friendly! Peter and Gabby were so helpful and accommodating to helping me pamper my kid! They know how to show hospitality. Thanks to you both!“

4.5 Superb116 Reviews
The Corner Slice Pizza •
172 N College Ave Suite C, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Dairy Free Cheese Pizza with Pepperoni
Cheese and Supreme Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Slice
Garlic Pretzel
Pepperoni Pizza
Meatball Pizza
Cheesy Bread
Meatballs
Bites

“This place rules. We came during open mic night after a crushing valentines shift. Pep pizza was destroyed, the beer was dismantled, local musicians played originals and a good and pleasant vibe was had by all.Corner slice 4 life. For realsies.“

4.6 Superb85 Reviews
Slyce Pizza Co. Pizza • $
163 W Mountain Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Artichoke Pesto
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Mac N Cheese
Cheese Slice
Slice Pizza
Veggie Pizza

“Great place for late night pizza slices or lunch. Pretty neat layout, community tables, spacious dining and always a variety of pizzas ready for choosing. Customer service was great as well! My slices seemed a bit on the dry-side. I had the BBQ Pineapple and the Pepperoni and Sausage slice. They were awesome! They may have been sitting out for a while before I got there. I’d go back though for a late night bite to eat!“

4.3 Superb115 Reviews
Nick's Restaurant And Bar Italian • $$
1100 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread with Marinara
Nick’S Famous Burger
Bucatini Carbonara
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Italian Grinder
Lasagna Dinner
Chicken Wings
Nick's Burger

“The margherita pizza was excellent. Real sauce heavy, which I love.Happy Hour was pretty sparse, drink wise. I also found it odd that it's offered only bar side.Kid's spaghetti and red sauce was tiny and came with no side.Had a bite of the wife's burger, really good.Staff is friendly.Parking: Great parking availability for the being right off College.“

4 Good132 Reviews
JJ's Wood Fired Pizza Pizza • $
4015 S Taft Hill Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread Dippers
Meatball Appetizer
Gluten Free Crust
Margherita Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Lasagna Pizza
Meat Lovers
Tiramisu
Cannoli

“Coming from NYC, I hold the bar high when it comes to pizza. JJ's pizza is very good, no matter which pie you get. It's not NY Pizza, nor do they claim to be; but they are very good for what they offer. I think you'll be very pleased with their product. Their service is top notch and the atmosphere is matched perfectly with what they offer. Good place ?“

4.3 Superb82 Reviews
La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches Pizza • $
234 N College Ave Unit B3, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Piadina with Prosciutto Stracchino and Arugula
Meatball
Daniele

“OMG!!!!! Yummmm. We went in wanting to try something different, we are so glad we did. The owner gave us a history lesson on the food we were eating too. Thank you so much for a delicious and delightful dining experience. We will return, and were bringing friends! Now on my list of craveables.❤️“

4.6 Superb42 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza • $
1880 N College Ave Unit 160, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch

“I haven't had dominos pizza for ages.. but decided to try it when I was out and about. It was good but perhaps a little over cooked . Not bad.. I was surprised that it tasted so good maybe I was just hungry. It was a large pizza.. but looked more like a medium. Service was fast. I may try it again. ??“

5 Superb22 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
1013 Centre Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Pineapple Pizza
PEPP Artichoke Black Olive Pizza
Hawaiin Mushroom Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own Salad
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Mad Dog Mod Size
Lots of Veggies
Gluten Free BYO
Hawaiian Pizza

“You wanna solid pizza the way you want it with fantastic service? Strongly recommend! Family friendly, fun atmosphere and indoor or outdoor seating. Each pizza is made to order and wait time from creation to finished pie is minimal! Easy access and parking! Whether eating in or taking out you will go back!Kid-friendliness: Kids will love it!“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Avogadro's Number American • $
605 S Mason St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Jalapeno Poppers
Veggie Steak Sub
Chicken Tenders
Joe's Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Tempeh Burger
Beyond Burger
Nitty Gritty
Onion Rings

“Lovely atmosphere, great space to sit and eat and vibe. The patio will definitely be a spot to come back to in warmer weather! The food was fantastic, staff was very kind, and the atmosphere was absolutely stunning. Loved the artwork and the attention to detail on the food.Vegetarian options: Great options, many selections and very helpful staffDietary restrictions: Staff is very accommodating and menu is clearly labeledParking: Easy to find when not slammed downtown“

4.1 Good97 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
238 E Harmony Rd Suite D9, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Chicken Garlic w O Sundried Tomatos
Create Your Own Half & Half Pizza Original Crust
Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza Baking Required
Create Your Own Crustless Keto Friendly
Chicken Bacon Artichoke Baking Required
Herb Chicken Mediterranean
Chicken Bacon Stuffed
Friday Thins Bundle
Thai Chicken
The Papa

“Best Papa Murphy's location I have ever been too!!! My order was ready when I arrived, the young lady working (06.15.2023 at 2:30pm) was such a kind and friendly human, she honestly deserves a raise for how amazing her customer service was and how she represents the Papa Murphy’s name. Furthermore, my pizza was honestly the best Papa Murphy’s pizza I think I have ever had. Because of these reasons I will continue to be a customer and frequent this location specifically.“

4.6 Superb29 Reviews
Otto Pint Pizza • $
1100 Oakridge Dr, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Burrata Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Build Your Own Pizza
Smoked Duck Pizza
Margherita Pizza
The Riviera Pizza
The Ziggy Pizza
Beer and Pizza
Custom Pizza
Meatballs
Pesto

“Cool atmosphere in a renovated gas station. Excellent salad. Neopolitan pizza is very thin crust like a cracker. Very loud in the middle of the room. Hostess was like a squirrel coming to the podium and walking away about 7 times before greeting us.“

4 Good107 Reviews
Cozzola's Pizza Pizza • $
1112 Oakridge Dr #114, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

The Meat Eater
Hawaiian
Sizes
Crust

“Absolutely phenomenal! Visiting from Utah. Literally THE BEST PIZZA we have ever had. The cheese over the abundance of toppings keeps everything together for a scrumptious bite! We had the Meat Eater (seriously ABUNDANCE of meats! Freaking awesome) and the Hawaiian. Let me say this. That basil red sauce with the Hawaiian is EVERYTHING!!!Thank you so much for the dancing of our taste buds!“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
Panino's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
310 W Prospect Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti & Meatballs
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Side of Marinara
Buffalo Chicken
Penne Bolognese
Build Your Own
Cheese Sticks
Greek Salad
House Salad

“Had a fabulous 18th birthday party in the group gathering room! Communication was SUPERB, service exemplary, and the food was delicious! Owner John Beck and manager on duty, Shelby, went above and beyond to make my daughter’s birthday fabulous!?“

4 Good95 Reviews
Beau Jo's Fort Collins Pizza • $
205 N College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Pizza
Margherita Pizza
The Motherlode
Pepperoni Pizza
Mountain Pizza
Great Pizza
BYO Calzone
Hipster
Nachos

“This was a take out order. It was ready and hot when I arrived. Beau Jo’s pizza is a unique version of classic pizza. The toppings are plentiful and super tasty. The crust like a side of great bread all on its own. But the abundant crust does not hurt the part of the pizza under the toppings, which is thin, and tasty too! A great Gourmet pizza that lives up to that monicker.“

3.9 Good173 Reviews
Daddy-O's Jr Sandwich Shop • $
4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

SM Turkey Bacon Club
Reg Santa Fe Chicken
Reg Tijuana Toaster
Reg Pastrami Reuben
SM Pastrami Reuben
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Reg Spicy Italian
Xtra Pickle Spear
Reg Turkey Reuben
Wisconsin Cheese

“I just ate here and was pretty impressed at the food and the service. The staff are really kind! And the food was tasty and looked nice when it came. Love the round bread, very unique and very tasty. I had the pastrami Ruben on rye, it was really good and not expensive. Would recommend and will return!“

4.2 Good41 Reviews
Panhandler's Pizza - Fort Collins, CO Pizza • $
2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicago-Style Sausage Pizza
Combo Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cheese Garlic Bread
Original Pan-Style
Slice of the Day
Deluxe Combo
Sauce

“This is literally the best pizza I’ve ever tasted in my entire life and I’ve been to Chicago! There is no other pizza that has such a distinct flavor. I crave it on a weekly basis. Thank you for staying the same and never changing your pizza. Best pizza ever!!!“

4 Good72 Reviews
Pizza Casbah Pizza Delivery • $
126 W Laurel St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Dipping Sauces
Cheese Slices
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Zeppolis
Marinara
Wings

“Thank you guys for making delicious pizza AND putting the customer first when there was a little power glitch. We have been coming here for years and you guys demonstrated why we always come back! (Awesome customer service, of course!)/24We ordered from here tonight and as usual, this place never allows themselves to have customers disappointed! I ordered a 24” and got a 12”. Whoever I spoke with on the phone owned the mistake and refused to have me drive to get my pizza. You are one of the reasons this place keeps their customers. I have been a customer since there was a little room upstairs to eat my pizza in, before renovations. I love this place and the employees are phenomenal. Thank you for being one of my favorite places to get pizza at. ? “

3.9 Good64 Reviews
Mama Roni's Pizza Pizza • $$
1006 Spring Creek Ln b4, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Roll
Colorado Pizza
Greek Salad
House

“Hunter at the timberline location was INCREDIBLE! He was super friendly and professional and made our pizza rolls exquisitely! Would definitely highly recommend this place! Fantastic food fantastic service and fair prices it's a win win for sure!“

3.9 Good48 Reviews
D.P. Dough Pizza • $
634 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

2 Calzones for 14 Winsday
Roni Zoni Takeout: Yes
Build Your Own Calzone
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Combat Zone
Cheese Zone
Cheese Stix
Tater Tots
Buffer Zone
Wings

“This Is hands-down, the best calzone I’ve ever had and the next time i will tip. I didn’t this time but I will time next time ! because of Delivery fees always assume that they’re getting something out of it but This is amazing food And they deserve extra couple dollars regardless I hope so makes it to the “

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Blackjack Pizza & Salads Pizza • $
4206 S College Ave #107, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Passion Pizza Large
Italian Sausage Pizza
16 Xtra Large Pizza
Jackpot Pizza
Cinnabread

“I LOVE this Blackjack. Been eating this 'za throughout Colorado my whole life. Let me say, the pizza is good, but the salads...*chef's kiss*. Huge salad, lots of fresh veggies, completely customizable (within their topping list), and delish! They've got a regular!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Pizza • $$
2670 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Southern Comfort Chicken Sandwich
Hot Fudge Brownie Pizookie
Bacon Cheeseburger
Avocado Egg Rolls
Bistro Burger
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings
Pita Tacos
Strawberry
Salad

“I like the menu. If you can't find something on their menu you are not hungry. Might as well just try one of their unique micro beers and watch some sports on one of their numerous big screen tvs. The food is really good and it only gets better after a beer or two.“

3.6 Good112 Reviews
Krazy Karl's Pizza and Sport Bar Pizza • $
1124 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Chicken Wings with Carrot Celery and Your Choice of Sauce
Garlic Parmesan Knots
North of the Border
Old World Pepperoni
Jalapeno Poppers
Pizza of the Week
Pepperoni Pizza
Spicy Ranch
Cobb Salad
Vegetarian

“Their Pizza ? is the Best I've ever found!! I don't ever stay as I'm not into Sports bars or any alcohol ? places, as the crowds can be usually lower frequencies at times... I simply went for the pizza after stopping by the local Kava spot & chocolatier date spot I love earlier. It was such a fun adventure❣️❣️Go for the food!! Fun treat spot ? ?? This location had better staff & quality pizza too compared to Loveland's (We had a rude lady there & they burnt our pizza in LL x1, so we never went bk!)FoCo's locations never get it wrong!! Always perfect❣️? 《Worth the Drive!!》Very kind & fun staff in FoCo❣️?“

3.5 Good89 Reviews
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Pizza • $
4709 S Timberline Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

California Chicken Sandwich
Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls
Bacon Cheddar Burger
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicago 7 Pizza
Italian Nachos
Buffalo Wings
Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread
Chicago 7

“The food was above average and I enjoyed everything I ordered. Prices are a bit on the high side and the service was a little lacking. Had to ask for drinks several times. All in all a pretty good choice for some pizza. The pizza rolls are amazing! The wings are insanely priced for what you get so avoid those.“

3.5 Good82 Reviews
Cosmo's Pizza Pizza • $
1401 W Elizabeth St, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza Pepperoni and Bacon
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Dipping Sauce
Half and Half
Calzones

“They are so busy because they’re so good. They are well staffed and everyone is patient and kind. Onto the food, I’m from NYC and hands down the best pizza I have had out west. Management is professional and fair as well as prices. 10000/10 recommend.“

3.5 Good45 Reviews
Loading...
map Map