27 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Collins

“I saw an ad for this place a while back. We drove an hour and half to come try it! I wish they were closer to us lol it was delicious, music was on point, the memorabilia was amazing and the staff were awesome!! We will definitely be back!!“

“Absolutely amazing! This might be the best pizza I’ve ever had. The chicken parm pizza is incredible. Splurge on the ricotta topping… it’s worth it! 2 slices was plenty for me. The only recommendation I have is for the restaurant to get metal utensils. The plastic knife left some plastic chips in the pizza and got dull quickly.“

“They’ve helped feed a hungry family of mine twice now and both times the food was excellent. I had a bit of an issue with the online ordering process, and the person on the phone just helped me out and placed my order for me. I appreciate the great food and customer service!“

“I love the corner slice and couldn't recommend it more. They have the best pizza and beer in town but what really makes this place the best is the awesome atmosphere. The staff are so friendly and knowledgeable. I especially love how they make the pizza right in front of you cause it’s fun to watch and you know what you’ll be eating! Best gluten free crust too. All the drinks are local which is extra awesome. They have got live music on Wednesdays and weekends as well. Good pizza, good beer, and good music. Perfect place!“

“We’ve tried almost every pizza place in town and Cozzola’s keeps becoming our go-to. The crust has that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the toppings actually taste fresh instead of overly processed. Pickup was right on time and the staff is always super friendly. Highly recommend the garlic bread and Hanna’s pizza if you’re trying them for the first time.“

“Excellent food, great staff. La Piadina is top drawer.“

“I went in, didn't find my pizza finished (I was early), and a fellow said, "It's right here. I'll get it done for you!"

I was bringing my wife back from eye surgery, and I really appreciated his swiftness, especially among the Tuesday crowd!

Of course, the pizza was made right as well.

Parking: Park over by the pet store. It's better than playing chicken with the other nut-jobs trying to get a sale-priced pizza!“

“Great pizza great service“

“Just had one of the best pizzas ever. Also the dipping sauce for bread sticks was delish. The experience was perfect.“

“I had pizza for dinner. The atmosphere was nice, clean and tidy. The food was reasonably priced, but the pizza had a very thin crust which I didn't like. It was too thin and crispy. The good thing was that you could choose all the toppings to add to your pizza. I got a medium pizza and two small pizzas with four sodas for $30.“

“This place is so good! The portions are huge and the food is delicious. Carmen our waitress was so attentive and friendly. Loved the atmosphere and their thin crust reminded me of Chicago pizza.“

“The food was great! There are no wrong options on the menu and I would recommend getting an appetizers and drink to fully enjoy the experience. I got the Pesto pizza which was really good and the Bolognese Rigatoni had amazing flavors and mild spiciness. There is plenty of indoor and outdoor seating options and easy access. Parking can be a little tight due to the volume of businesses in the area versus parking availability. But, would still recommend it!“

“Awesome service, pet friendly in outdoor seating area, and the Local Sausage Pizza was fabulous. Thanks Luke and Andrea.“

“been going for 40 years and I've always loved the place. no better pizza around.“

“With over 50 years of eating pizza, I can positively say Otto's has the best pizza on our floating blue marble. 1st time in ft.Collins and this was within walking distance of the hotel. Their pizza crust not to thin or think. You know when the pizza is when eat it end to end. The mozzarella cheese curds are just delicious. I had the spicy papa the two times I visited. Do not miss going here if you are anywhere close to Otto's. The staff was great, too!“

“Only tried the mountain crust pizza but it was really good 💯“

“I've never once had a bad experience at this location. This team consistently knocks it out of the park. I love that you still use on-staff delivery drivers instead of contracting to a third party delivery service that doesn't care. Every driver I've worked with has been friendly, courteous, and professional. Top notch!“

“Food as always very good. Service from Cortney was superb, great attitude and a real pro. Seasonal drinks...outstanding.“

“Best pizza EVER! Crust was amazing on the thin & crispy, done just the way I like it❤️“

“First timer!! Super impressed by the cleanliness of the interior and the design. Taken aback at the fact that they went so far to have branded straws for ovarian cancer awareness month. Talk about not pink washing but ACTUALLY going all in! Heck yeah! I can't wait to bring the rest of my family here!! The food is so good, and the service was really great.“

“I work at the north college kings just wanted to say thank you for the pizza!!!“

“Nothing but love, art, inclusion, tasty food & drinks, in this place!!!!“

“I would just like to quickly say thank you to Julian, Emily, Jake and Evan tonight for addressing an issue that I had and immediately providing a solution. This place always has wonderful friendly staff members, service, and quality food. 5 stars DP DOUGH!“

“Anthony's is my family's go-to spot for pizza. The pizza is delicious, and even better, it keeps well in the fridge. Beyond that, its made fresh in the resturaunt for each order; This is my only problem, since sometimes orders can take quite a long time. Beyond that, service is amazing.
One reccomendation I have however, is purchasing stronger paper plates, as the meat pizzas are extremely greasy, and eat thorugh the plate.

P.S. Shoutout to Nate for carrying the resturaunt last night.“

“Laci S. At at your Fort Collins location, was phenomenal! She was so sweet, made sure we got the best bang for our buck. Even gave my son extra cookies on top of it. My son was floored at how good the quality was, he said it was the best little Caesars pizza he's ever had. It was definitely hot & fresh. It was a 10 all the way around. She's a great manager extra kudos to her!“

“Delicious pizza at a great price, not a long wait for food.“

“The extra large New York style pizza is a steel at $9.99… However, you can only order it with plain cheese or pepperoni only. This is no problem for us as we ordered the pepperoni and go home and put on our other toppings before we bake it. This is one of the best deals in town. We use scissors to cut slices of the raw pizza, tray included, and then wrap and freeze for future use. Game changer.“