5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Erie

“Longtime customer, appreciate being able to order the pizza exactly the way we like it, at a reasonable price. Key is being able to bake it properly ourselves, which took some experimenting and the purchase of an Old Stone Pizza Peel so we could bake directly on the oven rack.“

“I just want to remark on the unbelievably fast delivery time. This is an ongoing thing too. I order pizza and the site says 45 mins for delivery. The food shows up on 20 mins, piping hot and from the friendliest dude ever! Great hire with the older gentleman delivering the food. I wish I knew his name so I could shout him out here. He has always been over the top friendly. The food quality is amazing and the food is super hot. GREAT experience all around. Thanks BLACKJACK Erie!!“

“Great vibes inside, tasty food, Ghostbusters Pinball, what’s not to love? In addition to The pinball machine they have a Neo-Geo cabinet and a Crusin USA cabinet, giving you plenty to do while you wait for your food. The wait may be a while as this is a smaller restaurant, but the food is worth waiting for.“

“Usually, this is a very good place. The food is excellent. The service is excellent I just didn’t like my breadsticks not coming out on time.“

“I don’t usually order pizza for delivery because it almost always shows up soggy, lukewarm, and disappointing. But this experience completely changed my mind.

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and an order of cheese sticks, and everything arrived hot, fresh, and tasted like it had just come out of the oven. It was easily the best Papa John’s I’ve ever had. The pizza was perfectly cooked, the cheese sticks were delicious, and the quality was way better than I expected.

A special shoutout to our delivery driver, Joel. He was friendly, professional, and made sure everything arrived quickly and in perfect condition.

If this is your local Papa John’s, you’re lucky. I’ll definitely be ordering from this location again.“