10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lafayette

“I grew up in Chicago - north side on true Chicago pizza - thin crust, lots of cheese and meat and cut in squares. Jimano’s is the real deal. Best pizza I have had since I don’t know when. Been searching for a place like this for decades. Two minor differences from the north side pizza of my childhood- the crust was oh so slightly thinner and crispier and the sausage grease wasn’t dripping off each slice - both pluses in my mind. Folks in the service industry could take a lesson or two in friendly and helpful behind the counter customer service from the two gents working and baking. The atmosphere is walk up to counter and 4 small square tables for dining but we were the only ones eating in and had a grand old time eating way too much pizza.“

“We have ordered delivery 2x from here and each time it has been amazing. Also nice that they do the delivery vs. another outside service. We got the cheese Bread, wings and specialty pizza all of which I would highly recommend. Everything was still very hot upon arrival.“

“everything about this place is awesome. great food great service friendly and fun atmosphere!!“

“I love the pizza here. It tastes much fresher than a lot of other pizzas in this price range. Also, I always have a great experience with the people working here. They are friendly and professional. It’s worth the extra drive from Erie for us!“

“We came in about 30 mins before closing and were treated so well by the staff! They delivered our pizza to our table, brought an extra plate because two of us were sharing, and cut the pizza to accommodate us without our asking for it! We have been to another Mod location in a similar situation and were treated very rudely because we came in too close to closing time. This was an entirely different and 100% better experience. Thank you for a delicious meal!“

“Great Neapolitan Pizza prepared and served by friendly, competent people for the nine years we've been Proto's loyalists.......🍕“

“Good food in a convenient location. Had lunch and I’ll go back soon.“

“ONLY ORDER AND PAY FROM THE STORE!!!! I’m not sure if the store is aware but Uber Eats is charging $18 for a 12inch pizza… when the pizza is only $7.55! I’m not sure if this is an Uber issue or store issue. However I will be contacting AMEX to have my money refunded from the up charge from a Uber no matter what. I did not get the product that was offered for the PRICE. Other than my rant, their pizza is AMAZING! Great local chain for Pizza and I highly recommend them and will continue to order directly from the store!“

“My husband and I had the most wonderful meal and dining experience at Bucatino's last week. Everyone from our waiter to the greeters to the servers and helpers and especially to the owner James made us truly feel like we were eating in family's home. Warm, welcoming and just so delicious! If you have not. tried Bucatino Trattoria Romana in Lafayette you are missing out on wonderful dining experience! Thank you to James, to your chef, and to all of your staff for putting so much care into what you do for all of us!“

“Mici's is great. I recently had to call MIci's because I hadn't received my order and discovered that it was listed as delivered. I have mobility issues and couldn't go around the neighborhood to find it so the manager sent one of his employees to my house to find the order for me. They were pleasant, kind, and went above and beyond the call of duty to make sure my order was taken care of. Mici's gave me such good customer service, and I am so thankful to have them in my neighborhood.“